Khasminsky Vadim, Auriel Eitan, Luckman Judith, Eliahou Ruth, Inbar Edna, Pardo Keshet, Landau Yuval, Barnea Rani, Mermelstein Maor, Shelly Shahar, Naftali Jonathan, Peretz Shlomi
From the Departments of Imaging (V.K., J.L., R.E., E.I.) and Neurology (E.A., K.P., R.B., M.M., J.N., S.P.), Rabin Medical Center, Petach Tikva, Israel; Sackler Faculty of Medicine (V.K., E.A., J.L., R.E., E.I., Y.L., R.B., S.P.), Tel Aviv University; Metabolic Diseases Clinic (Y.L.), Schneider Children's Medical Center, Petach Tikva; Department of Neurology (S.S.), Rambam Health Care Campus, Haifa, Israel; and Department of Neurology (S.S.), Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN.
Neurol Genet. 2023 Jul 5;9(4):e200082. doi: 10.1212/NXG.0000000000200082. eCollection 2023 Aug.
Stroke-like episodes (SLEs) in patients with mitochondrial encephalomyopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome are often misdiagnosed as acute ischemic stroke (AIS). We aimed to determine unique clinical and neuroimaging features for SLEs and formulate diagnostic criteria.
We retrospectively identified patients with MELAS admitted for SLEs between January 2012 and December 2021. Clinical features and imaging findings were compared with a cohort of patients who presented with AIS and similar lesion topography. A set of criteria was formulated and then tested by a blinded rater to evaluate diagnostic performance.
Eleven MELAS patients with 17 SLE and 21 AISs were included. Patients with SLEs were younger (median 45 [37-60] vs 77 [68-82] years, < 0.01) and had a lower body mass index (18 ± 2.6 vs 29 ± 4, < 0.01), more commonly reported hearing loss (91% vs 5%, < 0.01), and more commonly presented with headache and/or seizures (41% vs 0%, < 0.01). The earliest neuroimaging test performed at presentation was uniformly a noncontrast CT. Two main patterns of lesion topography with a stereotypical spatiotemporal evolution were identified-an anterior pattern (7/21, 41%) starting at the temporal operculum and spreading to the peripheral frontal cortex and a posterior pattern (10/21, 59%) starting at the cuneus/precuneus and spreading to the lateral occipital and parietal cortex. Other distinguishing features for SLEs vs AIS were cerebellar atrophy (91% vs 19%, < 0.01), previous cortical lesions with typical SLE distribution (46% vs 9%, = 0.03), acute lesion tissue hyperemia and venous engorgement on CT angiography (CTA) (45% vs 0%, < 0.01), and no large vessel occlusion on CTA (0% vs 100%, < 0.01). Based on these clinicoradiologic features, a set of diagnostic criteria were constructed for possible SLE (sensitivity 100%, specificity 81%, AUC 0.905) and probable SLE (sensitivity 88%, specificity 95%, AUC 0.917).
Clinicoradiologic criteria based on simple anamnesis and a CT scan at presentation can accurately diagnose SLE and lead to early administration of appropriate therapy.
This study provides Class III evidence that an algorithm using clinical and imaging features can differentiate stroke-like episodes due to MELAS from acute ischemic strokes.
线粒体脑肌病伴乳酸血症和卒中样发作(MELAS)综合征患者的卒中样发作(SLEs)常被误诊为急性缺血性卒中(AIS)。我们旨在确定SLEs独特的临床和神经影像学特征,并制定诊断标准。
我们回顾性纳入了2012年1月至2021年12月因SLEs入院的MELAS患者。将其临床特征和影像学表现与一组表现为AIS且病变部位相似的患者进行比较。制定了一套标准,然后由一名盲法评估者进行测试以评估诊断性能。
纳入了11例患有17次SLEs的MELAS患者和21例AIS患者。SLEs患者更年轻(中位年龄45[37 - 60]岁 vs 77[68 - 82]岁,<0.01),体重指数更低(18±2.6 vs 29±4,<0.01),更常报告听力丧失(91% vs 5%,<0.01),更常出现头痛和/或癫痫发作(41% vs 0%,<0.01)。就诊时最早进行的神经影像学检查均为非增强CT。确定了两种具有典型时空演变的主要病变部位模式——一种前部模式(7/21,41%)从颞叶岛盖开始并扩散至额叶周边皮质,一种后部模式(10/21,59%)从楔叶/楔前叶开始并扩散至枕叶外侧和顶叶皮质。SLEs与AIS的其他鉴别特征包括小脑萎缩(91% vs 19%,<0.01)、既往有典型SLE分布的皮质病变(46% vs 9%,=0.03)、CT血管造影(CTA)上急性病变组织充血和静脉淤血(45% vs 0%,<0.01)以及CTA上无大血管闭塞(0% vs 100%,<0.01)。基于这些临床放射学特征,构建了一套可能的SLE诊断标准(敏感性100%,特异性81%,AUC 0.905)和很可能的SLE诊断标准(敏感性88%,特异性95%,AUC 0.917)。
基于简单病史和就诊时CT扫描的临床放射学标准可准确诊断SLE,并有助于早期给予适当治疗。
本研究提供了III级证据,表明一种利用临床和影像学特征的算法可将MELAS所致的卒中样发作与急性缺血性卒中区分开来。