Department of Physical Therapy, Samford University, Birmingham, Alabama, USA.
Department of Physical Therapy, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama, USA.
J Spinal Cord Med. 2024 Nov;47(6):968-976. doi: 10.1080/10790268.2023.2231674. Epub 2023 Jul 10.
Neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) is often used to activate muscles impaired after spinal cord injury to elicit functional activities or to facilitate exercise. However, in addition to the cost and availability of NMES and the inherent muscle fatigue that is associated with its use may limit its widespread utilization. Optimizing stimulation parameters during NMES-induced contractions could maximize force production with less fatigue. To examine the interrelationship of pulse duration and pulse frequency on torque production and muscle fatigue in both impaired and non-impaired skeletal muscle of men and women. Individuals with [ = 14 (6 females), 38 ± 13 yr; 175 ± 11 cm; 76 ± 20 kg] and without [ = 14 (6 females), 29 ± 8 yr; 175 ± 9 cm; 74 ± 14 kg] spinal cord injury (SCI) participated. Muscle torque was recorded during a series of NMES-induced isometric muscle contractions using different combinations of pulse durations and frequencies. Additionally, two different muscle fatigue protocols (20 and 50 Hz/200µs) were utilized to elicit repeat isometric muscle contractions (1s on and 1s off × 3 min). There was a statistically significant linear trend for pulse charge (the product of pulse frequency and pulse duration) on isometric torque production in participants without (p < 0.001, η= 0.79), and in participants with SCI (p < 0.001, η= 0.66), with higher total pulse charge generating higher torque values. Participants with SCI had significantly greater muscle fatigue for both muscle fatigue protocols (p < 0.05). NMES protocols should consider using longer pulse durations with lower frequencies to maximize force production for individuals with SCI. However, because mechanisms of muscle fatigue may be different for impaired muscle when compared to non-impaired muscle, further studies on protocols to offset fatigue are warranted.
神经肌肉电刺激(NMES)常用于激活脊髓损伤后受损的肌肉,以产生功能性活动或促进运动。然而,除了 NMES 的成本和可用性以及与使用相关的固有肌肉疲劳可能会限制其广泛应用外,还可以优化 NMES 诱导收缩期间的刺激参数,以最少的疲劳产生最大的力。为了研究脉冲持续时间和脉冲频率对男性和女性受损和未受损骨骼肌的扭矩产生和肌肉疲劳的相互关系。参与者包括[= 14(6 名女性),38 ± 13 岁;175 ± 11 厘米;76 ± 20 千克]和没有[= 14(6 名女性),29 ± 8 岁;175 ± 9 厘米;74 ± 14 千克]脊髓损伤(SCI)的个体。使用不同的脉冲持续时间和频率组合,在一系列 NMES 诱导的等长肌肉收缩期间记录肌肉扭矩。此外,还利用两种不同的肌肉疲劳方案(20 和 50 Hz/200μs)引发重复的等长肌肉收缩(1s ON 和 1s OFF×3 分钟)。在没有 SCI 的参与者(p < 0.001,η= 0.79)和有 SCI 的参与者(p < 0.001,η= 0.66)中,等长扭矩产生与脉冲电荷量(脉冲频率和脉冲持续时间的乘积)呈统计学显著线性趋势,总脉冲电荷量越高,扭矩值越高。对于两种肌肉疲劳方案,SCI 参与者的肌肉疲劳都明显更大(p < 0.05)。NMES 方案应考虑使用较长的脉冲持续时间和较低的频率,以最大限度地提高 SCI 个体的力产生。然而,由于与未受损肌肉相比,受损肌肉的肌肉疲劳机制可能不同,因此需要进一步研究抵消疲劳的方案。