Smith Alexander, Buadze Anna, Stute Petra, Liebrenz Michael
Department of Forensic Psychiatry, University of Bern, Bern, 3012, Switzerland.
Department of Psychiatry, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, Psychiatric Hospital, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
F1000Res. 2023 Jul 20;12:219. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.130986.2. eCollection 2023.
Healthcare policy is an important societal concern in Switzerland, often dominating the national agenda. In other countries, studies have explored the influence of physicians in public office on healthcare policies, but little is known about the representation of medical doctors in Switzerland's political structures, despite ongoing health-related debates. : In January 2023, we examined the proportion of registered doctors currently serving in Swiss governmental branches: the executive (the Federal Council) and the legislative (the Council of States and the National Council, together the United Federal Assembly). We used publicly available information to demarcate Federal, State, and National Councillors with professional medical backgrounds. We subsequently verified physician registrations using the Federal Office of Public Health's "Register of Medical Professionals" (MedReg) : Six physicians registered in MedReg were identified across the Federal Council and the United Federal Assembly in 2023, equivalent to 2.37% of the total number of Councillors in these chambers. This corresponds to 14.20% of members in the Federal Council (the executive chamber) and 2.03% of members in the United Federal Assembly (the legislative chamber). : Rates of physicians sitting in Switzerland's Federal Council and United Federal Assembly are higher than general population trends for doctors per person. Nonetheless, physicians in Swiss legislative positions are proportionally lower than comparative data from the United States. We highlight how existing professional frameworks may already ensure medical doctors are sufficiently participating in Swiss healthcare debates outside of formal roles. We also suggest that more international evidence is needed to determine the benefits of physicians serving in public office.
医疗保健政策是瑞士社会关注的重要问题,常常主导国家议程。在其他国家,已有研究探讨担任公职的医生对医疗保健政策的影响,但尽管有关健康问题的辩论不断,对于瑞士政治结构中医生的代表性却知之甚少。2023年1月,我们调查了目前在瑞士政府部门任职的注册医生比例:行政部门(联邦委员会)和立法部门(州议会和国民议会,合称联邦议会)。我们利用公开信息来界定具有医学专业背景的联邦委员、州议员和国民议员。随后,我们使用联邦公共卫生办公室的“医学专业人员登记册”(MedReg)核实医生注册情况。2023年,在联邦委员会和联邦议会中,共识别出六名在MedReg登记的医生,占这些议院议员总数的2.37%。这相当于联邦委员会(行政议院)成员的14.20%和联邦议会(立法议院)成员的2.03%。瑞士联邦委员会和联邦议会中医生的比例高于人均医生的总体人口趋势。尽管如此,瑞士立法职位上的医生比例低于美国的可比数据。我们强调现有专业框架可能已经确保医生在正式角色之外充分参与瑞士医疗保健辩论。我们还建议需要更多国际证据来确定医生担任公职的益处。