Pediatrics, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio, USA
UH Rainbow Babies & Children's, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
BMJ Qual Saf. 2024 Jan 19;33(2):86-97. doi: 10.1136/bmjqs-2022-015786.
Emerging evidence has shown racial and ethnic disparities in rates of harm for hospitalised children. Previous work has also demonstrated how highly heterogeneous approaches to collection of race and ethnicity data pose challenges to population-level analyses. This work aims to both create an approach to aggregating safety data from multiple hospitals by race and ethnicity and apply the approach to the examination of potential disparities in high-frequency harm conditions.
In this cross-sectional, multicentre study, a cohort of hospitals from the Solutions for Patient Safety network with varying race and ethnicity data collection systems submitted validated central line-associated bloodstream infection (CLABSI) and unplanned extubation (UE) data stratified by patient race and ethnicity categories. Data were submitted using a crosswalk created by the study team that reconciled varying approaches to race and ethnicity data collection by participating hospitals. Harm rates for race and ethnicity categories were compared with reference values reflective of the cohort and broader children's hospital population.
Racial and ethnic disparities were identified in both harm types. Multiracial Hispanic, Combined Hispanic and Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander patients had CLABSI rates of 2.6-3.6 SD above reference values. For Black or African American patients, UE rates were 3.2-4.4 SD higher. Rates of both events in White patients were significantly lower than reference values.
The combination of harm data across hospitals with varying race and ethnicity collection systems was accomplished through iterative development of a race and ethnicity category framework. We identified racial and ethnic disparities in CLABSI and UE that can be addressed in future improvement work by identifying and modifying care delivery factors that contribute to safety disparities.
现有证据表明,住院儿童的伤害发生率存在种族和民族差异。之前的研究还表明,收集种族和民族数据的方法高度多样化,这给人群水平的分析带来了挑战。这项工作旨在创建一种按种族和族裔汇总多家医院安全数据的方法,并应用该方法来检查高频伤害情况中潜在的差异。
在这项横断面、多中心研究中,来自 Solutions for Patient Safety 网络的一组医院,具有不同的种族和族裔数据收集系统,按患者种族和族裔类别分层提交了经过验证的中心静脉置管相关血流感染(CLABSI)和计划外拔管(UE)数据。数据是使用研究团队创建的交叉表提交的,该交叉表协调了参与医院对种族和族裔数据收集的不同方法。将种族和族裔类别中的伤害率与反映队列和更广泛的儿童医院人群的参考值进行比较。
在两种伤害类型中都发现了种族和民族差异。多种族西班牙裔、混合西班牙裔和本土夏威夷或其他太平洋岛民患者的 CLABSI 率比参考值高出 2.6-3.6 个标准差。对于非裔或非裔美国患者,UE 率高出 3.2-4.4 个标准差。白人患者的这两种事件发生率明显低于参考值。
通过迭代开发种族和族裔类别框架,成功地将具有不同种族和族裔数据收集系统的医院的伤害数据结合在一起。我们确定了 CLABSI 和 UE 中的种族和民族差异,可以通过识别和修改导致安全差异的护理提供因素,在未来的改进工作中加以解决。