Kershner J, Hawke W
J Nutr. 1979 May;109(5):819-26. doi: 10.1093/jn/109.5.819.
The study investigated the effectiveness of large amounts of ascorbic acid, niacinamide, calcium pantothenate, and pyridoxine when added to a low carbohydrate-high protein diet with 20 learning disabled children. After a double-blind, 6-month period of treatment, the addition of vitamins to the diet failed to produce significant improvements when compared to the diet alone on a variety of intellectual, school achievement, perceptual, and behavioral, measures. Regardless of their group assignment, 18 children showed improvements on a parent-administered behavior checklist. However, without a diet-placebo control group, these gains may have been produced by parental enthusiasm or the children's maturation rather than dietary control. The children's urinary excretion of kryptopyrrole was unrelated to whether or not they showed pre-, post-test gains and, therefore, proved to be invalid as a screening test for "vitamin dependent (on pharmacologic doses) learning disorders."
该研究对20名学习障碍儿童进行了调查,在低碳水化合物高蛋白饮食中添加大量抗坏血酸、烟酰胺、泛酸钙和吡哆醇的效果。经过为期6个月的双盲治疗期后,与单纯饮食相比,在各种智力、学业成绩、感知和行为测量方面,饮食中添加维生素未能产生显著改善。无论其分组如何,18名儿童在家长管理的行为清单上显示出改善。然而,由于没有饮食安慰剂对照组,这些改善可能是由家长的热情或孩子的成熟导致的,而非饮食控制。儿童尿中尿卟啉原的排泄与他们在测试前后是否有进步无关,因此,作为“维生素依赖(药理剂量)学习障碍”的筛查测试被证明是无效的。