Health Professions Education Centre, Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland University of Medicine and Health Sciences, Dublin, Ireland.
Br J Hosp Med (Lond). 2023 Jul 2;84(7):1-9. doi: 10.12968/hmed.2022.0446. Epub 2023 Jul 18.
Clinicians spend a considerable part of their time while supervising trainees providing feedback. It is generally accepted that feedback can play a major role in subsequent academic performance. Traditionally it was thought that all feedback was good feedback, that inevitably improved learner outcomes. This has been challenged and it is now understood that feedback can have a beneficial or deleterious effect on the student. A number of factors can affect a learner's response to feedback. The concept of feedback literacy is helpful to understanding these responses - this describes the processes by which a learner makes sense of feedback and subsequently uses it to enhance learning. A learner who is feedback literate can recognise when they are getting feedback and understand how it relates to their progress; they can process it effectively both cognitively and emotionally, and they can put it in to action in ways which benefit their learning. Modifiable and non-modifiable factors can influence feedback literacy, with modifiable factors including feedback standards and supervisor behaviours. Providing clear feedback expectations, ensuring accuracy of feedback messages and focusing on the relationship between the teacher and learner have the most evidence for their effect on facilitating feedback literacy.
临床医生在指导学员时花费了相当一部分时间提供反馈。人们普遍认为,反馈可以在后续的学术表现中发挥重要作用。传统上,人们认为所有的反馈都是好的反馈,这不可避免地会提高学习者的学习成果。这种观点受到了挑战,现在人们明白,反馈对学生可能有有益的影响,也可能有有害的影响。许多因素会影响学习者对反馈的反应。反馈素养的概念有助于理解这些反应——它描述了学习者理解反馈并随后利用它来促进学习的过程。有反馈素养的学习者能够识别何时获得反馈,并了解反馈与他们的进步之间的关系;他们可以在认知和情感上有效地处理反馈,并以有利于他们学习的方式付诸行动。可改变和不可改变的因素会影响反馈素养,可改变的因素包括反馈标准和主管行为。提供明确的反馈期望,确保反馈信息的准确性,并关注教师和学习者之间的关系,这些因素对促进反馈素养的效果最有证据。