Department of Animal Science, The Pennsylvania State University, State College, PA 16802; ETH Zürich, Department of Environmental Science, Institute of Agricultural Sciences, Zürich 8092, Switzerland.
Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada J1M 0C8.
J Dairy Sci. 2023 Sep;106(9):6216-6231. doi: 10.3168/jds.2022-22966. Epub 2023 Jul 26.
The objective of this meta-analysis was to examine the effects of supplemental His on lactational performance, plasma His concentration and efficiency of utilization of digestible His (Eff) in dairy cows. The meta-analysis was performed on data from 17 studies published in peer-reviewed journals between 1999 and 2022. Five publications reported data from 2 separate experiments, which were included in the analyses as separate studies, therefore resulting in a total of 22 studies. In 10 studies, His was supplemented as rumen-protected (RP) His; in 1 study, 2 basal diets with different dHis levels were fed; and in the remaining experiments, free His was infused into the abomasum (4 studies), the jugular vein (3 studies) or deleted from a mixture of postruminally infused AA (4 studies). The main forages in the diets were corn silage in 14 and grass silage in 8 studies. If not reported in the publications, the supplies of dietary CP, metabolizable protein (MP), net energy of lactation, and digestible His (dHis) were estimated using NRC (2001). An initial meta-analysis was performed to test the standard mean difference (SMD; raw mean difference of treatment and control means divided by the pooled standard deviation of the means), that is, effect size, and the corresponding 95% confidence interval (CI) in production parameters between His-supplemented groups versus control. Further, regression analyses were also conducted to examine and compare the relationships between several response variables and dHis supply. Across studies, His supplementation increased plasma His concentration (SMD = 1.39; 95% CI: 1.17-1.61), as well as DMI (SMD = 0.240; 95% CI: 0.051-0.429) and milk yield (MY; SMD = 0.667; 95% CI: 0.468-0.866), respectively. Further, milk true protein concentration (MTP; SMD = 0.236; 95% CI: 0.046-0.425) and milk true protein yield (MTPY; SMD = 0.581; 95% CI: 0.387-0.776) were increased by His supplementation. Notably, the increase in MTP concentration and MTPY were 3.9 and 1.3 times greater for studies with MP-deficient (according to NRC 2001) diets compared with studies with MP-adequate diets. The regression analyses revealed that production parameters (DMI, MY, and MTPY) responded in a nonlinear manner to increasing His supply. Further, we detected a difference in the magnitude of change in MTPY and plasma His concentration with the level of His supply and between His supplementation methods, being greater for infused His compared with RPHis. Lastly, a linear and negative relationship between Eff and the ratio of total digestible His to net energy for lactation supply was observed, indicating an important interaction between dHis and energy supply and Eff (i.e., utilization of dHis to support protein export). Overall, these analyses confirm His as an important AA in dairy cattle nutrition.
本荟萃分析的目的是研究补充组氨酸对奶牛泌乳性能、血浆组氨酸浓度和可消化组氨酸(Eff)利用率的影响。荟萃分析基于 1999 年至 2022 年期间在同行评议期刊上发表的 17 项研究的数据进行。有 5 项出版物报告了来自 2 项独立实验的数据,这些数据被分别作为独立研究纳入分析,因此总共包含 22 项研究。在 10 项研究中,组氨酸作为瘤胃保护性(RP)组氨酸进行补充;在 1 项研究中,使用了 2 种具有不同 dHis 水平的基础日粮;而在其余的实验中,将游离组氨酸输注到皱胃(4 项研究)、颈静脉(3 项研究)或从后肠输注 AA 的混合物中去除(4 项研究)。日粮中的主要饲草为青贮玉米(14 项研究)和青贮草(8 项研究)。如果出版物中未报告,则使用 NRC(2001 年)估计日粮 CP、可代谢蛋白(MP)、泌乳净能和可消化组氨酸(dHis)的供应量。最初进行荟萃分析是为了测试生产参数中补充组氨酸组与对照组之间的标准均数差(SMD;处理和对照平均值的原始均数差除以平均值的合并标准差),即效应大小,以及相应的 95%置信区间(CI)。此外,还进行了回归分析,以检查和比较几种反应变量与 dHis 供应之间的关系。总的来说,组氨酸补充增加了血浆组氨酸浓度(SMD=1.39;95%CI:1.17-1.61)、DMI(SMD=0.240;95%CI:0.051-0.429)和牛奶产量(SMD=0.667;95%CI:0.468-0.866)。此外,牛奶真蛋白浓度(MTP;SMD=0.236;95%CI:0.046-0.425)和牛奶真蛋白产量(MTPY;SMD=0.581;95%CI:0.387-0.776)也因组氨酸补充而增加。值得注意的是,与 MP 充足的日粮研究相比,MP 缺乏(根据 NRC 2001)日粮研究中 MTP 浓度和 MTPY 的增加幅度分别高出 3.9 倍和 1.3 倍。回归分析表明,生产参数(DMI、MY 和 MTPY)对组氨酸供应的增加呈非线性响应。此外,我们还检测到 MTPY 和血浆组氨酸浓度随组氨酸供应水平的变化幅度以及组氨酸补充方式之间的差异,与 RP 组氨酸相比,输注组氨酸的变化幅度更大。最后,观察到 Eff 与可消化组氨酸与泌乳净能供应之比呈线性负相关,表明 dHis 和能量供应与 Eff(即利用 dHis 支持蛋白输出)之间存在重要的相互作用。总的来说,这些分析证实了组氨酸是奶牛营养中的重要 AA。