Arun S, Nayak Sunil S, Chithra A, Roy Sreea
Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Manipal College of Dental Sciences Manipal, Manipal Academy of Higher Education, Manipal, India.
J Maxillofac Oral Surg. 2023 Sep;22(3):634-640. doi: 10.1007/s12663-023-01863-1. Epub 2023 Feb 4.
With little evidence available in the literature, this study tries to clinically determine the efficiency and outcomes of non-surgical management of post-traumatic Zygomaticomaxillary complex (ZMC) fractures.
One hundred and three patients with post-traumatic isolated ZMC fractures managed conservatively for various reasons were identified. The patients were classified based on the Zingg et al. criteria into Types A, B, and C. We evaluated the resolution of signs and symptoms of six standard parameters over 6 months-persistent pain, restriction in mouth opening, infraorbital nerve (ION) paresthesia, aesthetic deformity, infraorbital step deformity with associated tenderness on palpation, and ophthalmic status. The study variables were then statistically analyzed using Cochran's Q test with an associated confidence interval of 95%.
A six-month follow-up revealed persisting residual deformities for all three groups. However, Type A and Type B showed significant improvement in pain reduction, mouth opening, and infraorbital nerve (ION) paresthesia. No significant improvement was noted in any of the groups for aesthetic deformity, infraorbital step deformity, and ophthalmic status. Type C, which had comminuted fracture patterns, exhibited significant defects in all the parameters. Significant inter-variable relationship between certain paired parameters was also observed.
The Type A group is most suited for non-surgical management. Type B with a mono-bloc fracture is a crucial group that demands broader, long-term studies to extract a proper treatment protocol. Type C with severe fracture displacement validates surgical correction.
鉴于文献中可用证据较少,本研究试图临床确定创伤后颧上颌复合体(ZMC)骨折非手术治疗的有效性和结果。
确定了103例因各种原因接受保守治疗的创伤后孤立性ZMC骨折患者。根据津格等人的标准将患者分为A、B和C型。我们评估了6个月内六个标准参数的体征和症状的缓解情况——持续性疼痛、张口受限、眶下神经(ION)感觉异常、美学畸形、眶下台阶畸形及触诊时有压痛,以及眼部状况。然后使用 Cochr an Q检验对研究变量进行统计分析,相关置信区间为95%。
六个月的随访显示,所有三组均存在持续的残余畸形。然而,A组和B组在疼痛减轻、张口度和眶下神经(ION)感觉异常方面有显著改善。在美学畸形、眶下台阶畸形和眼部状况方面,任何一组均未观察到显著改善。具有粉碎性骨折模式的C组在所有参数上均表现出明显缺陷。还观察到某些配对参数之间存在显著的变量间关系。
A组最适合非手术治疗。单块骨折的B组是一个关键组,需要更广泛、长期的研究以制定合适的治疗方案。骨折移位严重的C组证实需要手术矫正。