Damant Dominique, Boulebsol Carole, Roy Valerie, Trudeau Matis
School of Social Work, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Sciences Humaines Appliquées, Université de Montréal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Affilia. 2023 Aug;38(3):432-447. doi: 10.1177/08861099231159653. Epub 2023 Mar 20.
This article discusses the results of a collaborative research project aimed at understanding the life trajectories of women who have self-identified as having used violence in a context other than self-defense, which is an understudied topic. Based on semi-structured interviews and aided by an intersectional feminist framework applied to life course theory, we present a qualitative analysis of 26 women's experiences of violence, precarity, and services. The three groups of trajectories are distinguished by level of precarity as determined by the experience of violence in childhood, socioeconomic and family contexts, criminalization, intensity of violence, and whether the women received adequate support. This shows (1) the need for interventions to prevent the reproduction or aggravation of violence suffered and perpetrated; (2) the importance of considering the inter-related factors (gender, class race, etc.) that contribute to the women's precarity; and (3) that these factors must be considered to understand the contexts in which women have come to use violence, without trivializing or excusing it, but rather properly situating it with a view to better preventing and intervening in these situations. Our recommendations are aimed at ensuring that social work practices do not contribute to the enforcement of punitive measures, but support women in pursuing their path.
本文讨论了一个合作研究项目的结果,该项目旨在了解那些自我认定在非自卫情况下使用过暴力的女性的生活轨迹,这是一个研究较少的主题。基于半结构化访谈,并借助应用于生命历程理论的交叉性女权主义框架,我们对26名女性的暴力、不稳定及服务经历进行了定性分析。这三组轨迹根据不稳定程度来区分,不稳定程度由童年时期的暴力经历、社会经济和家庭背景、被定罪情况、暴力强度以及女性是否得到充分支持来决定。这表明:(1)需要进行干预,以防止所遭受和实施的暴力再次发生或加剧;(2)考虑促成女性不稳定的相互关联因素(性别、阶级、种族等)的重要性;(3)必须考虑这些因素,以了解女性使用暴力的背景,既不轻视或原谅这种行为,而是恰当地对其进行定位,以便更好地预防和干预这些情况。我们的建议旨在确保社会工作实践不会助长惩罚性措施的实施,而是支持女性走自己的路。