Alzheimer Center Amsterdam, Neurology, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam UMC Location VUmc, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Amsterdam Neuroscience, Neurodegeneration, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Alzheimers Res Ther. 2023 Aug 5;15(1):131. doi: 10.1186/s13195-023-01276-9.
The paradigm shift towards earlier Alzheimer's disease (AD) stages and personalized medicine creates new challenges for clinician-patient communication. We conducted a survey among European memory clinic professionals to identify opinions on communication about (etiological) diagnosis, prognosis, and prevention, and inventory needs for augmenting communication skills.
Memory clinic professionals (N = 160) from 21 European countries completed our online survey (59% female, 14 ± 10 years' experience, 73% working in an academic hospital). We inventoried (1) opinions on communication about (etiological) diagnosis, prognosis, and prevention using 11 statements; (2) current communication practices in response to five hypothetical cases (AD dementia, mild cognitive impairment (MCI), subjective cognitive decline (SCD), with ( +) or without ( -) abnormal AD biomarkers); and (3) needs for communication support regarding ten listed communication skills.
The majority of professionals agreed that communication on diagnosis, prognosis, and prevention should be personalized to the individual patient. In response to the hypothetical patient cases, disease stage influenced the inclination to communicate an etiological AD diagnosis: 97% would explicitly mention the presence of AD to the patient with AD dementia, 68% would do so in MCI + , and 29% in SCD + . Furthermore, 58% would explicitly rule out AD in case of MCI - when talking to patients, and 69% in case of SCD - . Almost all professionals (79-99%) indicated discussing prognosis and prevention with all patients, of which a substantial part (48-86%) would personalize their communication to patients' diagnostic test results (39-68%) or patients' anamnestic information (33-82%). The majority of clinicians (79%) would like to use online tools, training, or both to support them in communicating with patients. Topics for which professionals desired support most were: stimulating patients' understanding of information, and communicating uncertainty, dementia risk, remotely/online, and with patients not (fluently) speaking the language of the country of residence.
In a survey of European memory clinic professionals, we found a strong positive attitude towards communication with patients about (etiological) diagnosis, prognosis, and prevention, and personalization of communication to characteristics and needs of individual patients. In addition, professionals expressed a need for supporting tools and skills training to further improve their communication with patients.
向阿尔茨海默病(AD)早期阶段和个性化医疗的范式转变为医患沟通带来了新的挑战。我们对欧洲记忆诊所的专业人员进行了一项调查,以了解他们对(病因)诊断、预后和预防沟通的看法,并确定增强沟通技巧的需求。
来自 21 个欧洲国家的 160 名记忆诊所专业人员完成了我们的在线调查(59%为女性,14±10 年工作经验,73%在学术医院工作)。我们用 11 个陈述来列举(1)对(病因)诊断、预后和预防沟通的意见;(2)针对五个假设病例(AD 痴呆、轻度认知障碍(MCI)、主观认知下降(SCD),有(+)或无(+)异常 AD 生物标志物)的当前沟通实践;以及(3)关于十个列出的沟通技巧的沟通支持需求。
大多数专业人员认为,诊断、预后和预防方面的沟通应针对个体患者进行个性化。针对假设患者病例,疾病阶段影响了沟通病因性 AD 诊断的倾向:97%会明确向 AD 痴呆患者提及 AD 的存在,68%会向 MCI+患者提及,29%会向 SCD+患者提及。此外,58%会在与 MCI-患者交谈时明确排除 AD,69%会在 SCD-患者时排除 AD。几乎所有专业人员(79-99%)都表示会与所有患者讨论预后和预防,其中相当一部分(48-86%)会根据患者的诊断测试结果(39-68%)或患者的病史信息(33-82%)来个性化他们的沟通。大多数临床医生(79%)希望使用在线工具、培训或两者结合来支持他们与患者沟通。专业人员最希望获得支持的主题是:激发患者对信息的理解,以及沟通不确定性、痴呆风险、远程/在线,以及与不会(流利)讲居住国语言的患者沟通。
在对欧洲记忆诊所专业人员的调查中,我们发现他们对与患者沟通(病因)诊断、预后和预防以及根据患者的特征和需求进行沟通个性化持强烈的积极态度。此外,专业人员表示需要支持工具和技能培训,以进一步提高他们与患者的沟通能力。