Cao Fang, Sun Hao, Yang Zhenli, Bai Yanhua, Hu Xiao, Hou Yuhong, Bian Xiaocui, Liu Yuqin
Key Laboratory of Carcinogenesis and Translational Research (Ministry of Education), Department of Pathology, Peking University Cancer Hospital &Institute, Beijing, China.
Department of Pathology, Cell Resource Center, Institute of Basic Medical Sciences, Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences & School of Basic Medicine, Peking Union Medical College, Beijing, China.
Int J Cancer. 2024 Jan 1;154(1):155-168. doi: 10.1002/ijc.34677. Epub 2023 Aug 6.
The short-tandem-repeats (STR) profiles of MGc80-3 and HeLa partially overlap, raising suspicion of contamination in the MGc80-3 cell line. However, there has not been any relevant study demonstrating whether MGc80-3 was fully replaced by HeLa cells, just mixed with HeLa cells (co-existing), or was a somatic hybrid with HeLa cells. In addition to STR profiling, various approaches, including single nucleotide polymorphisms genotyping, polymerase chain reaction, screening for human papillomaviruses type 18 (HPV-18) fragment, chromosome karyotyping, pathological examination of xenografts, tissue-specific-90-gene expression signature and high-throughput RNA sequencing were used to determine the nature of MGc80-3. Our study found that the abnormal STR profile, partially overlapping with that of HeLa cells (64.62% to 71.64%), could not verify MGc80-3 as a HeLa cell line. However, the STR 13.3 repeat allele in the D13S317 locus that seemed to be unique to HeLa cells was detected in MGc80-3. Almost all the MGc80-3 cells exhibited HPV-18 fragments in the genome as well as certain HeLa marker chromosomes, such as M7 and M12. The molecular assay of the 90-gene expression signature still considered MGc80-3 as a stomach cancer using an algorithmic analysis. The expression pattern of multiple genes in MGc80-3 was quite different from that in HeLa cells, which showed that certain characteristics belonged to gastric cancer cell lines. High throughput RNA sequencing showed the distinct patterns of gene expression in MGc80-3. In conclusion, MGc80-3 cell line is a somatic hybrid with HeLa cells rather than a pure gastric cancer cell line.
MGc80-3和HeLa细胞的短串联重复序列(STR)图谱部分重叠,这引发了对MGc80-3细胞系污染的怀疑。然而,尚无任何相关研究证明MGc80-3是被HeLa细胞完全取代,只是与HeLa细胞混合(共存),还是与HeLa细胞形成了体细胞杂种。除了STR图谱分析外,还采用了多种方法,包括单核苷酸多态性基因分型、聚合酶链反应、18型人乳头瘤病毒(HPV-18)片段筛查、染色体核型分析、异种移植病理检查、组织特异性90基因表达特征分析和高通量RNA测序来确定MGc80-3的性质。我们的研究发现,与HeLa细胞部分重叠(64.62%至71.64%)的异常STR图谱无法证实MGc80-3是HeLa细胞系。然而,在MGc80-3中检测到了HeLa细胞特有的D13S317位点的STR 13.3重复等位基因。几乎所有MGc80-3细胞在基因组中都表现出HPV-18片段以及某些HeLa标记染色体,如M7和M12。通过算法分析,90基因表达特征的分子检测仍将MGc80-3视为胃癌细胞。MGc80-3中多个基因的表达模式与HeLa细胞有很大不同,这表明某些特征属于胃癌细胞系。高通量RNA测序显示了MGc80-3中独特的基因表达模式。总之,MGc80-3细胞系是与HeLa细胞形成的体细胞杂种,而非单纯的胃癌细胞系。