Dental Clinic - Department of Prosthodontics, Justus Liebig University, Schlangenzahl 14, 35392, Giessen, Germany.
Dental Clinic - Department of Pediatric Dentistry, Justus Liebig University, Schlangenzahl 14, 35392, Giessen, Germany.
BMC Med Educ. 2023 Aug 8;23(1):556. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04544-2.
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic has accelerated digital transformation in dental education, resulting in a shift from face-to-face teaching to online learning. While online learning could be a common strategy in various fields, the challenge for dental education is that it depends on the requirements of clinical experience to achieve competence in performing the dental treatment. This cross-sectional study aimed to analyse students' and lecturers' perceptions towards online learning after five semesters of experience using a questionnaire survey.
Since the spring term of 2020, the theoretical part of the curriculum has been conducted in the form of online learning using a combination of synchronous and asynchronous formats. In the following semesters, more theoretical content was shifted back from online learning to face-to-face courses. Preclinical and clinical students enrolled in the dental curriculum during the spring term 2022 semester and all lecturers with at least one year of teaching experience in face-to-face and online learning formats were asked to fill out an online questionnaire regarding the aspects of handling, didactic benefit, motivation, and overall assessment.
Students and lecturers rated the implementation of online learning as mostly positive, but pointed out that established 'face-to-face' learning could not be replaced. Moreover, the students reported personal benefits in terms of daily planning. Lecturers also benefitted as their experience increased in online teaching. For future curriculum, students demanded 49.5% (25.1) ((mean (standard deviation) of theoretical part in terms of online learning), while lecturers demanded only 34.1% (24.1).
Despite having no prior need for online learning, students and lecturers showed a positive perspective on online learning which should be considered in the implementation and planning of future dental education. However, in terms of practical training, it cannot replace face-to-face education in dentistry.
冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行加速了牙科教育的数字化转型,导致教学从面对面教学转向在线学习。虽然在线学习可能是各个领域的常见策略,但牙科教育的挑战在于,它依赖于临床经验的要求才能胜任牙科治疗。本横断面研究旨在通过问卷调查分析学生和讲师在经历五个学期的在线学习后的看法。
自 2020 年春季学期以来,课程的理论部分采用同步和异步格式相结合的在线学习形式进行。在随后的几个学期中,更多的理论内容从在线学习转回面对面课程。春季学期 2022 学期注册牙科课程的基础和临床学生以及至少有一年面对面和在线学习经验的所有讲师都被要求填写一份在线问卷,内容涉及处理、教学效益、动机和总体评估等方面。
学生和讲师对在线学习的实施评价大多为正面,但指出已建立的“面对面”学习无法替代。此外,学生报告在日常计划方面有个人收益。讲师的在线教学经验增加也使他们受益。对于未来的课程,学生要求在线学习理论部分占 49.5%(25.1),而讲师仅要求 34.1%(24.1)。
尽管学生和讲师之前没有在线学习的需求,但他们对在线学习表现出积极的态度,这应该在未来牙科教育的实施和规划中得到考虑。然而,就实践培训而言,它不能替代牙科的面对面教育。