Department of Orthopaedics, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah.
J Arthroplasty. 2024 Feb;39(2):527-532. doi: 10.1016/j.arth.2023.08.009. Epub 2023 Aug 11.
Arthroplasty is one of the least gender-diverse orthopaedic subspecialties. While previous studies have looked at factors influencing fellowship choices for women, few studies have attempted to understand the decision for or against arthroplasty specifically. Working to better understand fellowship choice is a critical step in the process of increasing women recruitment.
An anonymous survey was distributed using REDCap to women orthopaedic surgeons and trainees through listservs, social media groups, and residency programs. Surgeons who had decided on a specific subspecialty or already completed fellowship were included. Responses were obtained from 164 surgeons (72 arthroplasty surgeons, 92 other subspecialties). Chi-squared and Fisher's Exact tests were then performed.
The most important factor for those who chose arthroplasty was enjoyment of the surgeries. The biggest concerns from those in the arthroplasty group about the field were work-life balance, ability to become pregnant and/or have a healthy pregnancy, and sex bias from referring physicians. Of those who ultimately chose another subspecialty, 30.4% considered arthroplasty "a little" and 8.7% considered it "strongly." The most important dissuaders for the group that considered arthroplasty were concerns about "boy's club" culture, concerns about the physicality of the surgeries, and a lack of mentors.
While the decision to choose a career path is multifactorial, our hope is that through the identification of modifiable factors we can increase women representation in arthroplasty. Increasing mentorship, implementing practical solutions to improve work-life balance, supporting healthy pregnancies, and mitigating the physical demands of surgery could help address current disparities.
关节置换术是性别差异最小的矫形外科专业之一。尽管之前的研究已经探讨了影响女性选择 fellowship 的因素,但很少有研究试图具体了解选择或不选择关节置换术的决定。努力更好地理解 fellowship 的选择是增加女性招聘的关键步骤。
通过 REDCap 向女性骨科医生和住院医师通过列表服务、社交媒体群组和居住计划匿名分发了一份调查。包括已经决定特定亚专业或已经完成 fellowship 的外科医生。从 164 名外科医生(72 名关节置换外科医生,92 名其他亚专业)中获得了回复。然后进行了卡方和 Fisher 精确检验。
选择关节置换术的最重要因素是对手术的享受。关节置换组最关心的问题是工作与生活的平衡、怀孕和/或健康怀孕的能力,以及来自主治医生的性别偏见。最终选择其他亚专业的人中,30.4%认为关节置换术“有点”,8.7%认为“强烈”。考虑关节置换术的小组最主要的劝阻因素是对“男孩俱乐部”文化的担忧、对手术体力的担忧以及缺乏导师。
虽然选择职业道路是多因素的,但我们希望通过确定可改变的因素,能够增加女性在关节置换术领域的代表性。增加指导、实施改善工作与生活平衡的实际解决方案、支持健康怀孕和减轻手术的体力要求,可能有助于解决当前的差距。