Muentner Luke, Charles Pajarita
Department of Pediatrics, University of Minnesota Twin Cities, Minneapolis, MN.
Sandra Rosenbaum School of Social Work, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI.
Fam Relat. 2023 Jul;72(3):1068-1087. doi: 10.1111/fare.12739. Epub 2022 Jul 18.
This qualitative study examined adult perspectives on the adjustments children face through the process of paternal incarceration and eventual release.
While the United States leads the world in incarceration, 95% of imprisoned individuals return to community life. Despite poor outcomes for children with incarcerated fathers, less is known as to how they fair after fathers' release. Conceptualizing paternal incarceration and reentry as linked rather than disparate events, this study examines perspectives on family separation, reunification, and children's adjustment when fathers return from prison.
The sample consisted of 38 participants (19 previously incarcerated fathers, nine coparenting mothers, and 10 relatives) who shared perspectives on 63 children's adjustments. The semistructured interviews were analyzed via thematic analysis.
Two main themes were evident: (a) Paternal incarceration has a lasting toll on children that complicates reunification processes, introduces hurdles to maintaining togetherness, and is tied to changes in children's behaviors; and (b) reentry renews opportunity for father involvement that bolsters resilience despite ongoing systemic vulnerabilities.
Postrelease family reunification may present challenges for children's adjustment, though supported transitions may curb some concerns. The findings call for strengths-oriented, needs-focused, and evidence-based reentry strategies that support entire family systems.
本定性研究探讨了成年人对儿童在父亲入狱及最终获释过程中所面临调整的看法。
虽然美国的监禁率位居世界之首,但95%的被监禁者会回归社区生活。尽管父亲入狱的孩子面临不良后果,但对于他们在父亲获释后的情况却知之甚少。本研究将父亲入狱和重新融入社会视为相互关联而非毫不相干的事件,考察了父亲出狱后家庭分离、团聚以及孩子适应方面的看法。
样本包括38名参与者(19名曾被监禁的父亲、9名共同抚养孩子的母亲和10名亲属),他们分享了对63名儿童适应情况的看法。通过主题分析对半结构化访谈进行了分析。
两个主要主题很明显:(a)父亲入狱对孩子有持久影响,使团聚过程复杂化,给维持家庭完整带来障碍,并与孩子行为的变化有关;(b)重新融入社会为父亲参与提供了新机会,尽管存在持续的系统性脆弱性,但能增强孩子的适应能力。
出狱后的家庭团聚可能给孩子的适应带来挑战,不过得到支持的过渡可能会减少一些担忧。研究结果呼吁制定以优势为导向、以需求为重点且基于证据的重新融入社会策略,以支持整个家庭系统。