Department of Removable Partial Prosthodontics, Tokyo Dental College.
Department of Oral Health and Clinical Science Division of Dysphagia Rehabilitation.
Bull Tokyo Dent Coll. 2023 Dec 28;64(3):79-87. doi: 10.2209/tdcpublication.2022-0038. Epub 2023 Aug 18.
Dysphagia occurs in various diseases and constitutes a major concern in patients with psychiatric disorders. The Mann Assessment of Swallowing Ability (MASA) comprises 24 clinical parameters designed to identify swallowing disorders. One item in MASA, the "gag reflex", involves an unpleasant stimulus, which means that it is often omitted when the test is administered. The aims of this study were to determine the presence/absence of dysphagia in patients with psychiatric disorders using the MASA and determine its diagnostic accuracy when the gag reflex item was excluded in patients with psychiatric disorders. The study participants comprised patients admitted to a hospital psychiatric ward in whom dysphagia had been suspected based on oral intake status. The following items were determined: age, total MASA score (23 out of 24 items, giving a score out of 195 points), body mass index score, milligram equivalents of chlorpromazine, and the Food Intake Level Scale score. The patients were divided into two groups according to the presence or absence of swallowing problems as assessed by videoendoscopic or videofluoroscopic examination. The scores for each item investigated in the MASA, including the total score, were compared between the two groups. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was carried out to determine the optimum cut-off value. The total MASA score, which excluded the "gag reflex" item, was lower in the problematic swallowing group than in the non-problematic swallowing group. The MASA scores for cooperation, respiratory, dysphasia, tongue coordination, oral preparation, pharyngeal phase, and pharyngeal response tended to be lower in the problematic swallowing group. Furthermore, an optimum cut-off value of 169 points (sensitivity, 0.92; specificity, 0.68; likelihood ratio, 2.84) was identified. These results indicate that the cut-off MASA score is effective in screening for dysphagia, even when the "gag reflex" item is excluded.
吞咽障碍可发生于各种疾病,是精神障碍患者的主要问题之一。吞咽能力评估量表(MASA)包含 24 项临床参数,旨在识别吞咽障碍。MASA 的一个项目“咽反射”涉及到不愉快的刺激,这意味着在进行测试时经常被省略。本研究旨在使用 MASA 确定精神障碍患者是否存在吞咽障碍,并确定在排除精神障碍患者的“咽反射”项目时,该测试的诊断准确性。研究参与者包括因口腔摄入状态而怀疑吞咽困难而被收入医院精神科病房的患者。确定了以下项目:年龄、总 MASA 评分(24 项中的 23 项,得分为 195 分)、体重指数评分、氯丙嗪毫克当量和食物摄入水平量表评分。根据视频内镜或荧光透视检查评估患者是否存在吞咽问题,将患者分为两组。比较两组之间 MASA 中每个项目的评分,包括总分。进行受试者工作特征曲线分析以确定最佳截断值。排除“咽反射”项目后的总 MASA 评分在有吞咽问题的组中低于无吞咽问题的组。合作、呼吸、构音障碍、舌协调、口腔准备、咽部阶段和咽部反应的 MASA 评分在有吞咽问题的组中倾向于较低。此外,确定了 169 分的最佳截断值(灵敏度 0.92;特异性 0.68;似然比 2.84)。这些结果表明,即使排除“咽反射”项目,截断 MASA 评分也可有效筛查吞咽障碍。