Department of Child, Family, and Population Health Nursing, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA.
King County Department of Adult and Juvenile Detention, Seattle, WA, USA.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Aug 22;23(1):881. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-09809-6.
There are ongoing efforts to eliminate juvenile detention in King County, WA. An essential element of this work is effectively addressing the health needs of youth who are currently detained to improve their wellbeing and reduce further contact with the criminal legal system. This formative study sought to inform adaptation and piloting of an evidence-based systems engineering strategy - the Systems Analysis and Improvement Approach (SAIA) - in a King County juvenile detention center clinic to improve quality and continuity of healthcare services. Our aims were to describe the priority health needs of young people who are involved in Washington's criminal legal system and the current system of healthcare for young people who are detained.
We conducted nine individual interviews with providers serving youth. We also obtained de-identified quantitative summary reports of quality improvement discussions held between clinic staff and 13 young people who were detained at the time of data collection. Interview transcripts were analyzed using deductive and inductive coding and quantitative data were used to triangulate emergent themes.
Providers identified three priority healthcare cascades for detention-based health services-mental health, substance use, and primary healthcare-and reported that care for these concerns is often introduced for the first time in detention. Interviewees classified incarceration itself as a health hazard, highlighting the paradox of resourcing healthcare quality improvement interventions in an inherently harmful setting. Fractured communication and collaboration across detention- and community-based entities drives systems-level inefficiencies, obstructs access to health and social services for marginalized youth, and fragments the continuum of care for young people establishing care plans while detained in King County. 31% of youth self-reported receiving episodic healthcare prior to detention, 15% reported never having medical care prior to entering detention, and 46% had concerns about finding healthcare services upon release to the community.
Systems engineering interventions such as the SAIA may be appropriate and feasible approaches to build systems thinking across and between services, remedy systemic challenges, and ensure necessary information sharing for care continuity. However, more information is needed directly from youth to draw conclusions about effective pathways for healthcare quality improvement.
华盛顿州金县正在努力消除青少年拘留所。这项工作的一个重要组成部分是有效地满足目前被拘留的青少年的健康需求,以提高他们的幸福感,并减少他们与刑事法律系统的进一步接触。这项基础研究旨在告知在金县少年拘留中心诊所实施基于证据的系统工程策略-系统分析和改进方法(SAIA)的调整和试点,以改善医疗服务的质量和连续性。我们的目标是描述参与华盛顿州刑事法律系统的年轻人的优先健康需求,以及目前被拘留的年轻人的医疗保健系统。
我们对 9 名为年轻人服务的提供者进行了个别访谈。我们还获得了在数据收集时被拘留的 13 名年轻人与诊所工作人员之间进行的质量改进讨论的匿名定量摘要报告。使用演绎和归纳编码对访谈记录进行了分析,并使用定量数据对新出现的主题进行了三角测量。
提供者确定了基于拘留的健康服务的三个优先医疗保健级联-心理健康、药物使用和初级保健-并报告说,这些问题的护理通常是在拘留时首次引入的。受访者将监禁本身归类为健康危害,突出了在本质上有害的环境中为改善医疗保健质量干预措施提供资源的悖论。拘留和社区为基础的实体之间沟通和协作的破裂导致系统层面的效率低下,阻碍了边缘化青年获得健康和社会服务的机会,并使金县少年在被拘留时制定护理计划的护理连续性碎片化。31%的年轻人自我报告在拘留前接受过间歇性医疗保健,15%的人报告在进入拘留前从未接受过医疗保健,46%的人担心在释放到社区后找不到医疗保健服务。
系统工程干预措施,如 SAIA,可能是建立跨服务和服务之间系统思维、纠正系统挑战以及确保护理连续性所需信息共享的适当和可行方法。然而,需要更多来自年轻人的信息,以得出关于改善医疗保健质量的有效途径的结论。