School of Public Health, Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China.
School of Management, Shanxi Medical University, Taiyuan, China.
BMC Public Health. 2023 Aug 24;23(1):1611. doi: 10.1186/s12889-023-16547-1.
The debate on the relationship between social capital and health is still ongoing. To enhance previous research, this study uses data drawn from China to analyse the situations in which social capital is related to good health and the various configurations that result in good health outcomes.
Using the data of China Family Panel Studies, the conditions of age, gender, marriage, education, income, structural social capital and cognitive social capital were included to analyse the sufficient and necessary conditions for achieving good general health and their different configurations using the fsQCA method.
None of the listed conditions were prerequisites for excellent general health in terms of either their presence or their absence. The sufficiency analysis found 11 configurations with an average of 3-4 conditions per configuration; in no configuration was the condition of social capital present alone. Structured social capital and cognitive social capital exhibited negative states in configurations 1 and 2, respectively. The most prevalent factor in all configurations was the condition of age.
The relationship between social capital and health is both positive and negative, with cognitive social capital playing a larger role in the positive relationship than structural social capital. Social capital is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for health, and it must be combined with a variety of other factors to promote health. A variety of methods can be used to promote an individual's health, as different populations require different approaches to good general health, and no single pathway applies to all populations. In the Chinese population, an individual's age is a significant determinant of their health status.
关于社会资本与健康之间的关系的争论仍在继续。为了增强先前的研究,本研究使用来自中国的数据来分析社会资本与健康之间的关系,并分析导致健康结果的各种配置。
本研究使用中国家庭追踪调查的数据,将年龄、性别、婚姻、教育、收入、结构社会资本和认知社会资本等条件纳入其中,采用 fsQCA 方法分析实现良好总体健康的充分和必要条件及其不同配置。
在所列出的条件中,无论是存在还是不存在,都没有一个是实现良好总体健康的先决条件。充分性分析发现了 11 种配置,每种配置平均有 3-4 种条件;在没有一种配置中,社会资本的条件是单独存在的。结构社会资本和认知社会资本在配置 1 和 2 中分别呈现出消极状态。在所有配置中最常见的因素是年龄条件。
社会资本与健康之间的关系是双重的,既有积极的关系,也有消极的关系,认知社会资本在积极关系中比结构社会资本发挥更大的作用。社会资本既不是健康的必要条件,也不是充分条件,它必须与多种其他因素相结合才能促进健康。可以使用多种方法来促进个人的健康,因为不同的人群需要不同的方法来实现良好的总体健康,没有一种方法适用于所有人群。在中国人群中,个体的年龄是其健康状况的重要决定因素。