Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Harvard University, Boston, MA, United States.
University of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, AL, United States.
Front Public Health. 2023 Aug 4;11:1195005. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2023.1195005. eCollection 2023.
Human trafficking (HT) awareness campaigns can educate the public and specific professional figures about this crime and ways to prevent it. However, there currently remains a gap in terms of how to best frame such campaigns without stigmatizing groups of individuals or portraying victims in unrealistic ways.
We conducted four focus groups with 22 experts in HT to explore their perspectives and opinions on current challenges in the framing of HT awareness campaigns in the United States. Focus groups were conducted via Zoom and transcribed verbatim. Two independent reviewers analyzed the transcripts to identify themes using an inductive approach. The results of the focus groups analysis were used to structure the guiding questions of a brainstorming technique named Nominal Group Technique (NGT). Fifteen of 22 experts that participated in the focus groups joined the in-person NGT with the intent of generating ideas and achieving consensus on target audiences, goals, and content of human trafficking awareness campaigns. At the end of the NGT participants ranked priority for actions in the development of HT awareness efforts in the United States.
During the NGT the experts provided a number of recommendations to improve HT awareness and to empower victims to reach for help. They pointed to the need for: awareness efforts that describe HT on a spectrum of human abuse and exploitation; training for professional figures about trauma-informed care and communication; and efforts that empower trafficked victims to seek support. They also pointed to the need to develop awareness efforts tailored to local needs in close collaborations with the community-based organizations that can champion their dissemination and be the primary point of access for victims seeking help.
人口贩运(HT)意识宣传活动可以教育公众和特定专业人士了解这一犯罪行为及其预防方法。然而,目前在如何最好地设计这些活动方面仍然存在差距,以免污名化某些群体或以不切实际的方式描绘受害者。
我们与 22 名 HT 方面的专家进行了四次焦点小组讨论,以探讨他们对美国当前 HT 意识宣传活动框架方面的挑战的看法和意见。焦点小组通过 Zoom 进行,并逐字记录下来。两位独立的审阅者使用归纳方法分析了记录,以确定主题。焦点小组分析的结果用于构建头脑风暴技术(即名义群体技术,NGT)的指导问题。在 22 位参加焦点小组的专家中,有 15 位参加了现场 NGT,旨在就目标受众、目标和人口贩运意识宣传活动的内容集思广益并达成共识。在 NGT 结束时,参与者对在美国开展 HT 意识工作的发展进行了行动优先级排序。
在 NGT 期间,专家们提出了许多建议,以提高对 HT 的认识并赋予受害者寻求帮助的能力。他们指出需要:宣传活动描述人类虐待和剥削的范围;对专业人士进行创伤知情护理和沟通方面的培训;以及赋予被贩运受害者寻求支持的能力。他们还指出,有必要根据当地的需求,与能够支持其传播并成为寻求帮助的受害者主要切入点的社区组织密切合作,制定有针对性的宣传活动。