Danzon-Chambaud Samuel
School of Communications, Dublin City University, Dublin, Ireland.
Open Res Eur. 2021 Mar 24;1:4. doi: 10.12688/openreseurope.13096.1. eCollection 2021.
The use of advanced algorithmic techniques is increasingly changing the nature of work for highly trained professionals. In the media industry, one of the technical advancements that often comes under the spotlight is automated journalism, a solution generally understood as the auto generation of journalistic stories through software and algorithms, without any human input except for the initial programming. In order to conduct a systematic review of existing empirical research on automated journalism, I analysed a range of variables that can account for the semantical, chronological and geographical features of a selection of academic articles as well as their research methods, theoretical backgrounds and fields of inquiry. I then engaged with and critically assessed the meta-data that I obtained to provide researchers with a good understanding of the main debates dominating the field. My findings suggest that the expression "automated journalism" should be called into question, that more attention should be devoted to non-English speaking scholarship, that the collective and individual impacts of the technology on media practitioners should be better documented and that well-established sociological theories such as institutionalism and Bourdieu's field theory could constitute two adequate frameworks to study automated journalism practices. This systematic literature therefore provides researchers with an overview of the main challenges and debates that are occurring within the field of automated journalism studies. Future studies should, in particular, make use of institutionalism and field theory to explore how automated journalism is impacting the work of media practitioners, which could help unearth common patterns across media organisations.
先进算法技术的应用正日益改变着受过高度训练的专业人员的工作性质。在媒体行业,经常成为焦点的技术进步之一是自动化新闻,这一解决方案通常被理解为通过软件和算法自动生成新闻报道,除了初始编程外无需任何人工输入。为了对现有的关于自动化新闻的实证研究进行系统综述,我分析了一系列变量,这些变量可以解释一系列学术文章的语义、时间顺序和地理特征,以及它们的研究方法、理论背景和研究领域。然后,我对获得的元数据进行了研究和批判性评估,以便让研究人员很好地理解主导该领域的主要争论。我的研究结果表明,“自动化新闻”这一表述值得质疑,应更多关注非英语国家的学术研究,应更好地记录该技术对媒体从业者的集体和个人影响,并且诸如制度主义和布迪厄的场域理论等成熟的社会学理论可以构成研究自动化新闻实践的两个适当框架。因此,这一系统的文献综述为研究人员提供了自动化新闻研究领域内正在发生的主要挑战和争论的概述。未来的研究尤其应该利用制度主义和场域理论来探索自动化新闻如何影响媒体从业者的工作,这可能有助于挖掘不同媒体组织之间的共同模式。