Soil erosion caused by water refers to the removal of topsoil by rainfall and runoff. Proper selection of an assessment method is crucial for quantifying the spatial variance of soil erosion. The Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) and its revised version (RUSLE) are widely used for modelling soil erosion. This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the USLE-based soil erosion modelling in different agroecological regions of India, identify potential issues, and provide suggestions for future applications. The review revealed that little attention has been given to estimate soil erosion in high-priority land degradation regions of India. Additionally, many studies failed to thoroughly verify the authenticity of stated soil loss rates in their research regions either by overestimating or underestimating at least one of the five soil loss parameters. Furthermore, flaws in the application of methods to calculate these parameters leading to erroneous values were identified and suggestions for improvement were made. The USLE-based soil erosion modelling is an effective tool for quantifying soil erosion risk, but researchers should put emphasis on thoroughly verifying the methodologies adopted, unit conversions, and data availability for the estimation of soil loss parameters to improve the accuracy of their final results. This paper provides valuable insights to assist researchers in implementing USLE-based erosion models in diverse agroecological regions in India and elsewhere. However, for effective soil conservation and sustainable agriculture, further research is necessary to develop efficient techniques for using USLE-based soil erosion modelling to achieve a comprehensive understanding of erosion risk across different agroecological regions.