Essence of the Giant Reduction of Power Density in Osmotic Energy Conversion in Porous Membranes: Importance of Testing Area.

Harvesting osmotic energy through nanofluidic devices with diverse materials has received considerable attention in recent years. Often, a small testing area on a membrane was chosen to assess its power performance by calculating power density as output power per effective area. Since the choice of this testing area is arbitrary, and it is usually quite small, the result obtained can be too optimistic. There is a need to come up with a common standard so that the performance of a device/membrane can be assessed reasonably. In this study, we systematically investigate the power density as a function of testing area in nanoporous anodic-aluminum-oxide membranes. Through changing the aperture size of substrates, we clearly show that the obtained power density decreases drastically with increasing testing area. For instance, the power density acquired from the testing area of μm-scale can be five orders of magnitude larger than that from the pristine membrane of cm-scale. We also advance simulations by building a 3D model to simulate osmotic-driven ion transport in the multichannel system. The result of modeling agrees with our experimental observation that the power density decreases with increasing number of channels, and the ionic concentration profile reveals that the concentration polarization becomes serious as the number of channels increases. Our result highlights the importance of effective area on testing the power performance in nanofluidic devices.