Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2024 Jan-Feb;59(1):143-164. doi: 10.1111/1460-6984.12949. Epub 2023 Sep 4.
Children with Tourette syndrome (TS) have historically experienced problems in academic and social settings, yet their language and communication abilities have not been extensively researched.
This scoping review maps the literature on the oral language and social communication abilities of children with TS in order to describe the nature of the current literature, present a summary of major findings and identify where gaps exist.
A scoping review was completed to identify studies measuring the oral language or social communication abilities of children with TS. A systematic search of six electronic databases was conducted to obtain published and unpublished literature. All English studies measuring the oral language or social communication abilities of children with TS were included. Information was extracted from records and knowledge was synthesised in a narrative summary.
We identified 56 records for inclusion. Almost all records were located in journals within the fields of psychology and psychiatry. Skills most often studied were verbal IQ and verbal fluency. The literature suggests an increased prevalence of language disorders and social communication problems in children with TS; however, literature comprehensively detailing these challenges was scarce. Language strengths were identified in verbal intelligence, story/sentence recall, categorisation and performance on tasks at the single-word level.
Oral language and social communication skills are important for academic and social success. This review brings scattered literature together to provide up-to-date information about language in children with TS and highlights that there are considerable gaps in our knowledge about language and communication in this population. This scoping review can inform future research and support speech language pathologists in the assessment of young people with TS.
What is already known on the subject Speech-language pathologists (SLPs) working in various contexts (e.g., schools, mental health teams) are likely to encounter children with Tourette syndrome (TS); however, the description of this population and potential communication characteristics is not well represented in the SLP literature. Previous literature reviews have reported strengths in verbal fluency and morphological processing. Challenges in expressive language, higher order language, social cognition and a propensity towards autistic traits have also been identified. What this paper adds to existing knowledge This review differs from previous narrative reviews by employing a systematic approach to searching for literature. As a result, we identified 25 additional studies that had not been cited in previous reviews and additional relevant findings in 23 previously reviewed studies. This review confirms several previous conclusions about language in children with TS and extends or clarifies several others, thereby providing the most current information on oral language and social communication abilities. The use of current taxonomies of language and social communication helps to organise this literature for clinicians and researchers in speech-language pathology and identifies a need for further research from the SLP perspective. What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work? These results imply that SLPs should screen children with TS for language disorders and investigate social communication and social interaction development. Clinicians can expect greater challenges in language and communication development for children with complex forms of TS (i.e., those who exhibit co-occurring conditions such as attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder). The multidisciplinary nature of the current literature implies that clinical collaboration with other disciplines will be of particular benefit to serving this group of children.
患有妥瑞氏症(TS)的儿童在学术和社交环境中历来存在问题,但他们的语言和沟通能力尚未得到广泛研究。
本范围综述旨在描述 TS 儿童的口语语言和社交沟通能力的文献,以描述当前文献的性质,总结主要发现,并确定存在的差距。
完成了范围综述,以确定衡量 TS 儿童口语语言或社交沟通能力的研究。对六个电子数据库进行了系统搜索,以获取已发表和未发表的文献。纳入了所有衡量 TS 儿童口语语言或社交沟通能力的英语研究。从记录中提取信息,并以叙述性摘要的形式综合知识。
我们确定了 56 项符合条件的记录。几乎所有记录都来自心理学和精神病学领域的期刊。研究最多的技能是言语智商和言语流畅性。文献表明 TS 儿童语言障碍和社交沟通问题的发生率较高;然而,详细描述这些挑战的文献却很少。在言语智力、故事/句子回忆、分类和单字任务表现方面,语言优势明显。
口语语言和社交沟通技能对于学术和社交成功至关重要。本综述将零散的文献汇集在一起,提供了有关 TS 儿童语言的最新信息,并强调了我们对该人群语言和沟通的知识存在相当大的差距。本范围综述可以为未来的研究提供信息,并为评估 TS 青少年的言语语言病理学家提供支持。
在各种环境(例如学校、心理健康团队)工作的言语语言病理学家(SLP)可能会遇到患有妥瑞氏症(TS)的儿童;然而,该人群的描述和潜在的沟通特征在 SLP 文献中并未得到很好的体现。以前的文献综述报告了言语流畅性和形态处理方面的优势。在表达性语言、高级语言、社会认知以及自闭症倾向方面也存在挑战。
本综述与之前的叙述性综述不同,它采用了系统的方法来搜索文献。因此,我们确定了 25 项以前综述中未引用的额外研究,并在 23 项以前综述的研究中发现了额外的相关发现。本综述证实了之前关于 TS 儿童语言的几个结论,并扩展或澄清了其他几个结论,从而提供了有关口语语言和社交沟通能力的最新信息。使用当前的语言和社交沟通分类法有助于为言语语言病理学领域的临床医生和研究人员组织这些文献,并确定从 SLP 角度进一步研究的需求。
这方面工作的潜在或实际临床意义是什么?
这些结果意味着 SLP 应该对 TS 儿童进行语言障碍筛查,并调查社交沟通和社会互动发展情况。对于具有复杂形式 TS(即表现出注意力缺陷/多动障碍等共病情况的儿童)的儿童,语言和沟通发展可能会面临更大的挑战。目前文献的多学科性质意味着与其他学科的临床合作将特别有益于服务于这群儿童。