Nehring L, Kranabetter J M, Harper G J, Hawkins B J
Centre for Forest Biology, University of Victoria, PO Box 3020, STN CSC, 3800 Finnerty Road,Victoria, British Columbia V8P 5C2, Canada.
British Columbia Ministry of Forests, PO Box 9536, Stn Prov Govt, 4300 North Road, Victoria, British Columbia V8Z 5J3, Canada.
Tree Physiol. 2023 Dec 12;43(12):2064-2075. doi: 10.1093/treephys/tpad110.
Tree-ring δ15N may depict site-specific, long-term patterns in nitrogen (N) dynamics under N2-fixing species, but field trials with N2-fixing tree species are lacking and the relationship of temporal patterns in tree-ring δ15N to soil N dynamics is controversial. We examined whether the tree-ring δ15N of N2-fixing red alder (Alnus rubra Bong.) would mirror N accretion rates and δ15N of soils and whether the influence of alder-fixed N could be observed in the wood of a neighboring conifer. We sampled a 27-year-old replacement series trial on south-eastern Vancouver Island, with red alder and coastal Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirb.] Franco) planted in five proportions (0/100, 11/89, 25/75, 50/50 and 100/0) at a uniform stem density. An escalation in forest floor N content was evident with an increasing proportion of red alder, equivalent to a difference of ~750 kg N ha-1 between 100% Douglas-fir versus 100% alder. The forest floor horizon also had high δ15N values in treatments with more red alder. Red alder had a consistent quadratic fit in tree-ring δ15N over time, with a net increase of $\sim$1.5‰, on average, from initial values, followed by a plateau or slight decline. Douglas-fir tree-ring δ15N, in contrast, was largely unchanged over time (in three of four plots) but was significantly higher in the 50/50 mix. The minor differences in current leaf litter N content and δ15N between alder and Douglas-fir, coupled with declining growth in red alder, suggests the plateau or declining trend in alder tree-ring δ15N could coincide with lower N2-fixation rates, potentially by loss in alder vigor at canopy closure, or down-regulation via nitrate availability.
树轮δ¹⁵N可能描绘了固氮物种下特定地点氮(N)动态的长期模式,但缺乏对固氮树种的田间试验,并且树轮δ¹⁵N的时间模式与土壤氮动态之间的关系存在争议。我们研究了固氮红桤木(Alnus rubra Bong.)的树轮δ¹⁵N是否会反映土壤的氮积累速率和δ¹⁵N,以及相邻针叶树的木材中是否能观察到桤木固定氮的影响。我们在温哥华岛东南部对一个27年生的替代系列试验进行了采样,红桤木和海岸花旗松(Pseudotsuga menziesii [Mirb.] Franco)以五种比例(0/100、11/89、25/75、50/50和100/0)种植,茎密度均匀。随着红桤木比例的增加,林地氮含量明显上升,相当于100%花旗松与100%桤木之间相差约750 kg N ha⁻¹。在红桤木较多的处理中,林地层的δ¹⁵N值也较高。随着时间的推移,红桤木的树轮δ¹⁵N呈现出一致的二次拟合,平均而言,相对于初始值净增加约1.5‰,随后趋于平稳或略有下降。相比之下,花旗松树轮δ¹⁵N随时间基本不变(四个样地中的三个),但在50/50混合比例中显著更高。桤木和花旗松当前落叶的氮含量和δ¹⁵N的微小差异,再加上红桤木生长的下降,表明桤木树轮δ¹⁵N的平稳或下降趋势可能与较低的固氮率相吻合,这可能是由于树冠郁闭时桤木活力的丧失,或者是通过硝酸盐有效性的下调。