Department of Anatomy, Kogi State University, Anyigba, Kogi, Nigeria.
Department of Anatomy, Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2024 Jun;20(2):614-626. doi: 10.1007/s12024-023-00711-5. Epub 2023 Sep 9.
Sex determination is one of the fundamental procedures in the forensic investigation during personal identification. Foot dimensions, prints, indices, and angles are assessment tools used by podiatrists and forensic anthropologists. The arch index remains a tool for clinical evaluation of the incidence of pes planus by clinicians. This cross-sectional study was performed to investigate sexual dimorphism and discriminate sex using foot and footprint dimensions, foot angles, and foot indices among the Ebira ethnic group of Nigeria. Bilateral foot outlines and prints were obtained from 317 females and 283 males using a digital Vernier caliper, improvised footpad, and A4 paper. The results revealed that in the right foot and print, the males' bare right foot length (BRFL), bare right foot breadth (BRFB), right arch index (RAI), right Chippaux-Smirak index (RCSI), right footprint angle (RFPA), right ball angle (RBA), and all the measurements of the corresponding toes in the prints are significantly greater (p < 0.05) than the females. The same trend was also observed in the left footprint except for the left ball angle (LBA). The stepwise, binary logistics regression model for sex determination showed that bare left foot breadth (BLFB) and bare right foot length (BRFL) were the single best predictors of sex with an accuracy of 72.5% and 71.7% accuracy. Other foot variables marginally increased the percentage accuracy at each step. The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis confirmed the sexing potential of the bare left foot breadth and bare right foot length to be 79%. Sexual dimorphism exists in all the foot dimensions, arch indices, Chippaux-Smirak indices, footprint angles, and ball angles, except the left ball angle. The sexual dimorphism in the foot variables forms the basis of sex determination, with left foot breadth and right foot length as the best sex predictors. Therefore, 25 cm can be regarded as the cut-off point for foot length and 9 cm as the cut-off point for foot breadth among this tribe.
性别鉴定是个人身份识别中法医调查的基本程序之一。足部尺寸、脚印、指数和角度是足病医生和法医人类学家使用的评估工具。足弓指数仍然是临床医生评估扁平足发生率的临床评估工具。本横断面研究旨在调查尼日利亚埃比拉族群体的足部和足迹尺寸、足部角度和足部指数的性别二态性和性别判别。使用数字游标卡尺、自制足垫和 A4 纸从 317 名女性和 283 名男性中获得双侧足轮廓和脚印。结果表明,在右脚和脚印中,男性的裸右足长(BRFL)、裸右足宽(BRFB)、右足弓指数(RAI)、右 Chippaux-Smirak 指数(RCSI)、右脚印角度(RFPA)、右脚球角度(RBA)和脚印中所有相应脚趾的测量值均显著大于女性(p<0.05)。除了左足球角度(LBA)外,左脚脚印也呈现出同样的趋势。用于性别鉴定的逐步、二元逻辑回归模型表明,裸左足宽(BLFB)和裸右足长(BRFL)是性别预测的最佳单一预测因子,准确率为 72.5%和 71.7%。其他足部变量在每个步骤都略有增加了准确率。接收者操作特性(ROC)曲线分析证实,裸左足宽和裸右足长的性别鉴定潜力为 79%。所有足部尺寸、足弓指数、Chippaux-Smirak 指数、脚印角度和足球角度都存在性别二态性,除了左足球角度。足部变量的性别二态性构成了性别鉴定的基础,其中左足宽和右足长是最佳的性别预测因子。因此,25cm 可以被视为该部落中足部长度的截止点,9cm 可以被视为足部宽度的截止点。