Older J
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1986 Oct(211):36-42.
The data from a series of patients operated upon by Charnley and reviewed after ten to 12 years shows that low-frictional torque arthroplasty remains a sound concept of design. If done with precision, it is still the best operation for patients with discomfort and disability from coxarthrosis. The development of a sound interface is controlled not only by the initial strength of the interlock achieved by the surgeon, but also by the loads applied to it by the patients. The total hip arthroplasty may be a miracle of modern medicine, but it can never be superior to normal articulation; this should encourage the surgeon to steer the patient away from unreasonable expectations. In this review, 217 arthroplasties were performed in 184 patients; 58 died, leaving 153 arthroplasties in 126 patients. Eighty-eight percent were more than satisfactory; 6% required revision. This was due to aseptic loosening in only two percent.
查恩利对一系列患者进行手术,并在术后10至12年进行复查,数据表明低摩擦扭矩关节成形术在设计理念上依然合理。如果手术操作精准,对于因髋关节病而感到不适和残疾的患者来说,它仍是最佳手术方式。良好界面的形成不仅取决于外科医生实现的初始锁定强度,还取决于患者施加于其上的负荷。全髋关节置换术可能是现代医学的一个奇迹,但它绝不可能优于正常关节;这应促使外科医生避免患者产生不合理的期望。在此次复查中,184例患者接受了217例关节成形术;58例患者死亡,126例患者中剩余153例关节成形术。88%的手术效果非常令人满意;6%需要翻修。其中因无菌性松动导致翻修的仅占2%。