Department of Psychology, Tulane University.
Department of Psychology, Siena College.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2024 Nov;153(11):2751-2770. doi: 10.1037/xge0001475. Epub 2023 Sep 25.
Historically, psychological models of how people make judgments of discrimination have relied on a binary conceptualization of intergroup relations, making it unclear how people make judgments of discrimination in diverse, multigroup contexts. We propose that groups can vary in the extent to which they fit the prototype for targets of discrimination and that this variation influences judgments of discrimination in ambiguous circumstances. The present research examined attributions to discrimination when job applicants are rejected for a white-collar position. People consistently made more attributions to discrimination (ATDs) when managers rejected Black American as compared to Asian American job applicants, and when managers rejected Asian American as compared to White American job applicants. People also made more ATDs for rejected Black American as compared to Latino American applicants, but ATDs were similar for Latino and Asian American applicants. Overall, similar patterns were observed in majority White American samples and a Black/African American sample; only an Asian American sample did not make more ATDs for rejected Black than Asian American applicants. Six experiments ( = 2,321) found strong support for the relative fit hypothesis and suggest that, in a white-collar employment context, White Americans are a distant fit to the prototype for targets of discrimination, Asian and Latino Americans are an intermediate fit, and Black Americans are a close fit. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
从历史上看,人们对歧视的判断的心理学模型依赖于群体间关系的二元概念化,因此不清楚人们如何在多样化的多群体环境中对歧视做出判断。我们提出,群体在多大程度上符合歧视目标的原型是不同的,这种差异会影响模糊情况下的歧视判断。本研究考察了在白领职位申请者被拒绝时对歧视的归因。与拒绝亚裔美国申请者相比,当经理拒绝非裔美国申请者时,人们更倾向于将拒绝归因于歧视(ATD);与拒绝白人美国申请者相比,当经理拒绝亚裔美国申请者时,人们更倾向于将拒绝归因于歧视。与拉丁裔美国申请者相比,人们也更倾向于将 ATD 归因于被拒绝的非裔美国申请者,但拉丁裔和亚裔美国申请者的 ATD 相似。总体而言,在以白种人为主的美国样本和一个非裔美国样本中观察到了类似的模式;只有亚裔美国样本没有对被拒绝的黑人比亚裔美国申请者做出更多的 ATD。六项实验(=2321)有力地支持了相对适合度假设,并表明在白领就业环境中,白人是歧视目标原型的遥远契合者,亚洲人和拉丁裔是中等契合者,而非裔美国人则是紧密契合者。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2024 APA,保留所有权利)。