McAuliffe Úna, Woods Noel, Barrett Shauna, Cronin Jodi, Whelton Helen, Harding Máiréad, Eaton Kenneth, Burke Sara
Oral Health Services Research Centre, University College Cork, Cork, Co Cork, T12E8YV, Ireland.
School of Public Health, University College Cork, Cork, Co Cork, T12K8AF, Ireland.
HRB Open Res. 2022 Jan 17;5:5. doi: 10.12688/hrbopenres.13458.1. eCollection 2022.
Oral diseases have the highest global prevalence rate among all diseases, with dental caries being one of the most common conditions in childhood. A low political priority coupled with a failure to incorporate oral health within broader health systems has contributed to its neglect in previous decades. In response, calls are emerging for the inclusion of oral health within the universal healthcare domain (UHC). This protocol outlines the methodology for a cross-country comparative analysis of publicly funded oral health systems for children across six European countries, reporting on oral health status in line with the indicators for UHC. This study will follow Yin's multiple case study approach and employ two strands of data collection, analysis, and triangulation: a systematic documentary analysis and semi-structured interviews with elite participants local to each country. The countries chosen for comparison and providing a representative sample of European dental systems are Denmark, Hungary, the Republic of Ireland, Germany, Scotland, and Spain. A systematic search of five electronic databases and four additional electronic resources will be undertaken, in addition to grey literature and other publicly available sources, with the outcomes verified and further informed by local experts. The WHO Universal Health Coverage Cube will be used to guide data collection and analysis. This research will provide policy makers with an in-depth analysis and comparison of publicly funded oral health systems for children in Europe, including consideration of effective preventive strategies, oral health system reform, and indicators of universal oral health coverage. It is anticipated that the outcomes may help in positioning oral health on governmental health agendas and support its integration into wider health systems' reform in an accessible and affordable manner.
口腔疾病在所有疾病中全球患病率最高,龋齿是儿童期最常见的病症之一。过去几十年,由于政治上的重视程度较低,且未能将口腔健康纳入更广泛的卫生系统,导致其被忽视。作为回应,将口腔健康纳入全民医疗保健领域(UHC)的呼声日益高涨。本方案概述了对六个欧洲国家儿童公共资助口腔卫生系统进行跨国比较分析的方法,按照全民医疗保健指标报告口腔健康状况。本研究将遵循殷的多案例研究方法,采用两条数据收集、分析和三角互证的路径:系统的文献分析以及对每个国家当地精英参与者进行半结构化访谈。选择进行比较并能代表欧洲牙科系统的国家有丹麦、匈牙利、爱尔兰共和国、德国、苏格兰和西班牙。除灰色文献和其他公开可用来源外,还将对五个电子数据库和另外四个电子资源进行系统检索,结果由当地专家核实并提供更多信息。将使用世界卫生组织全民健康覆盖立方体来指导数据收集和分析。本研究将为政策制定者提供对欧洲儿童公共资助口腔卫生系统的深入分析和比较,包括对有效预防策略、口腔卫生系统改革以及全民口腔健康覆盖指标的考量。预计研究结果可能有助于将口腔健康纳入政府卫生议程,并支持以可及且负担得起的方式将其纳入更广泛的卫生系统改革。