Research Institute of Child Development and Education (RICDE), University of Amsterdam.
Dev Psychol. 2023 Oct;59(10):1839-1851. doi: 10.1037/dev0001591.
Child temperament has long been viewed as a potential susceptibility factor in the link between parenting and child disruptive behavior (CDB). Specifically, the idea is that children with higher negative emotionality, surgency, and lower effortful control are more affected by their received parenting, but experimental evidence is scarce. Also, others have argued that child temperament might not be a susceptibility factor but a factor that can change through parents' participation in a parenting intervention. To test both hypotheses, we analyzed pretest, posttest, and 4-month follow-up data from 386 mostly Dutch parents, mainly mothers (92%; Mage = 38.1, SD = 4.8) with children (Mage = 6.31, SD = 1.33; 54.2% boys). The children had above-average disruptive behavior (i.e., ≥75th percentile Eyberg Child Behavior Inventory questionnaire; Eyberg & Pincus, 1999). The families participated in a randomized controlled trial of the Incredible Years (IY) parenting program. Hierarchical regression analyses showed that child temperament did not moderate IY intervention effects on CDB. Furthermore, parallel process analyses showed that the IY intervention led to direct, simultaneous decreases in both negative emotionality and CDB. These findings counter the widely held belief that temperament traits are static, unchangeable modulators of the links between parenting and CDB. Instead, child temperament (negative emotionality) can at least partly be influenced by parents' participation in a parenting program. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).
儿童气质长期以来一直被视为父母教养与儿童破坏性行为(CDB)之间关系的潜在易感性因素。具体来说,人们认为情绪反应高、冲动、自控力低的儿童更容易受到所接受的父母教养的影响,但实验证据很少。此外,也有人认为儿童气质可能不是一个易感性因素,而是一个可以通过父母参与育儿干预而改变的因素。为了检验这两种假设,我们分析了来自 386 名主要是荷兰父母(92%为母亲;Mage=38.1,SD=4.8)及其子女(Mage=6.31,SD=1.33;54.2%为男孩)的前测、后测和 4 个月随访数据。这些孩子的破坏性行为高于平均水平(即 Eyberg 儿童行为问卷得分≥75 百分位;Eyberg & Pincus,1999)。这些家庭参加了一项随机对照试验,评估了“Incredible Years”(IY)育儿计划的效果。层次回归分析表明,儿童气质并不能调节 IY 干预对 CDB 的影响。此外,平行过程分析表明,IY 干预导致负面情绪和 CDB 同时直接下降。这些发现与普遍认为气质特征是父母教养与 CDB 之间关系的静态、不可改变的调节因素的观点相悖。相反,儿童气质(负面情绪)至少可以部分受到父母参与育儿项目的影响。