Affiliated Hospital of Chifeng University, Yuanlin Road 98, Chi Feng, 150400, Neimenggu, China.
Sci Rep. 2023 Oct 1;13(1):16489. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-42807-6.
Multiple methods have been proposed for evaluating the symmetry of facial contour by utilizing the median sagittal plane of the skull as a reference and measuring the maxillofacial region. To replace the manual mark point analysis method, we used the anterior cerebral falx plane in MRI images as an indicator of the craniofacial midline. The MRI examination data of 30 individuals were analyzed with a MeVisLab workstation. Two independent examiners performed 15 anthropometric measurements (4 angular, 11 linear) and compared the MRI-based anterior cerebral falx plane with the manual mark point analysis of the craniofacial midline estimation. All measurements were repeated after 3 weeks. Statistical analyses included the repeatability and reproducibility of the 2 methods based on intra-observer and inter-observer correlation coefficients (ICCs), respectively. Precision was estimated by intergroup comparison of the coefficient of variation. The anterior falx plane derived from the MRI data resulted in an intra-observer ICC of 0.869 ± 0.065 (range 0.733-0.936) and inter-observer ICC of 0.876 ± 0.0417 (0.798-0.932) for all measurements, showing significant correlations with the ICC values obtained by the mark point method (p < 0.05). The coefficient of variation showed that the precisions of the 2 methods were statistically comparable. We conclude that, for MRI-based craniofacial midline estimation, measurements made using the anterior cerebral falx plane are as precise, repeatable, and reproducible as those using the manual mark point analysis method. It has a high potential for application in radiation-free 3-dimensional craniofacial analysis.
已经提出了多种方法来评估面部轮廓的对称性,这些方法利用颅骨的正中矢状面作为参考,并测量颌面区域。为了替代手动标记点分析方法,我们使用 MRI 图像中的大脑前镰状线作为颅面中线的指标。使用 MeVisLab 工作站分析了 30 个人的 MRI 检查数据。两名独立的检查者进行了 15 项人体测量(4 个角度,11 个线性),并比较了基于 MRI 的大脑前镰状线与颅面中线估计的手动标记点分析。所有测量均在 3 周后重复。统计分析包括基于观察者内和观察者间相关系数(ICC)的两种方法的重复性和再现性。通过组间比较变异系数来估计精度。MRI 数据得出的前镰状线在所有测量中,观察者内 ICC 为 0.869±0.065(范围为 0.733-0.936),观察者间 ICC 为 0.876±0.0417(0.798-0.932),与标记点方法获得的 ICC 值显著相关(p<0.05)。变异系数表明,两种方法的精度具有统计学可比性。我们得出结论,对于基于 MRI 的颅面中线估计,使用大脑前镰状线进行的测量与使用手动标记点分析方法一样精确、可重复且可再现。它在无辐射的三维颅面分析中有很高的应用潜力。