Department of Anthropology, Southern Methodist University, Dallas, TX, USA.
Department of Anthropology, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, USA.
Nat Ecol Evol. 2023 Dec;7(12):2028-2036. doi: 10.1038/s41559-023-02212-8. Epub 2023 Oct 2.
Remote islands in the Pacific Ocean (Oceania) experienced dramatic environmental transformations after initial human settlement in the past 3,000 yr. Here, human causality of this environmental degradation has been unquestioned and viewed as evidence of the inherent destructive tendencies of human societies in both archaeological and popular discourse. We use charcoal and stable carbon isotopes from deep soil cores to reconstruct the dynamics of fire activity and deforestation across the Sigatoka River valley on the leeward (dry) side of Viti Levu, Fiji. Fires and pyrogenic patches of grassland predated human settlement by millennia, but the magnitude of fire activity and landscape transformation accelerated with the establishment and expansion of swidden agriculture. Regional comparisons with previous studies in Fiji and elsewhere in Remote Oceania settled between 3,200 and 2,900 yr BP reveal a similar pattern of pre- and post-settlement fire activity and landscape change. Pre-settlement fires generally corresponded to droughts, probably driven by El Niño, often correlating with drought-driven wildfires elsewhere in the region. Post-settlement, charcoal and C grasses increased dramatically, but nearly all major peaks in charcoal and grasses corresponded to increased El Niño activity. This indicates that fire activity and deforestation were a product of the interaction between swidden agriculture and climate rather than land use alone.
太平洋(大洋洲)的偏远岛屿在过去 3000 年的人类初始定居后经历了剧烈的环境变化。在这里,人类对这种环境退化的因果关系一直没有被质疑,并被视为考古学和通俗话语中人类社会固有破坏性倾向的证据。我们使用来自深层土壤芯的木炭和稳定的碳同位素来重建斐济维提莱武岛背风(干燥)一侧西加托卡河河谷火灾活动和森林砍伐的动态。火灾和草原火斑在人类定居前几千年就已经存在,但随着刀耕火种农业的建立和扩张,火灾活动和景观的变化幅度加快了。与斐济和其他偏远大洋洲地区之前在 3200 至 2900 年前进行的研究进行区域比较,揭示了类似的定居前和定居后火灾活动和景观变化模式。定居前的火灾通常与干旱有关,可能是由厄尔尼诺现象驱动的,通常与该地区其他地区干旱引发的野火有关。在定居后,木炭和 C 草的含量急剧增加,但几乎所有木炭和草的主要峰值都与厄尔尼诺活动的增加相对应。这表明火灾活动和森林砍伐是刀耕火种农业和气候相互作用的产物,而不仅仅是土地利用的结果。