Applied Muscle Development Laboratory, Department of Exercise Science and Recreation, CUNY Lehman College, Bronx, NY, USA.
Department of Physical Education and Sport, Faculty of Sport Sciences, University of Granada, Granada, Spain.
J Sports Sci. 2023 Jun;41(12):1207-1217. doi: 10.1080/02640414.2023.2261090. Epub 2023 Oct 24.
This study compared the effects of supervised versus unsupervised resistance training (RT) on measures of muscle strength and hypertrophy in resistance-trained individuals. Thirty-six young men and women were randomly assigned to one of two experimental, parallel groups to complete an 8-week RT programme: One group received direct supervision for their RT sessions (SUP); the other group performed the same RT programme in an unsupervised manner (UNSUP). Programme variables were kept constant between groups. We obtained pre- and post-study assessments of body composition via multi-frequency bioelectrical impedance analysis (MF-BIA), muscle thickness of the upper and lower limbs via ultrasound, 1 repetition maximum (RM) in the back squat and bench press, isometric knee extension strength, and countermovement jump (CMJ) height. Results showed the SUP group generally achieved larger increases in muscle thickness for the triceps brachii, all sites of the rectus femoris, and the proximal region of the vastus lateralis. MF-BIA indicated increases in lean mass favoured SUP. Squat 1RM was greater for SUP; bench press 1RM and isometric knee extension were similar between conditions. CMJ increases modestly favoured UNSUP. In conclusion, our findings suggest that supervised RT promotes greater muscular adaptations and enhances exercise adherence in young, resistance-trained individuals.
本研究比较了监督式与非监督式抗阻训练(RT)对接受过抗阻训练的个体的肌肉力量和肥大的影响。36 名年轻男性和女性被随机分配到两个实验性平行组中的一个,以完成 8 周的 RT 计划:一组接受 RT 课程的直接监督(SUP);另一组以非监督的方式进行相同的 RT 计划(UNSUP)。两组之间保持方案变量不变。我们通过多频生物电阻抗分析(MF-BIA)获得研究前后的身体成分评估,通过超声获得上肢和下肢的肌肉厚度,后深蹲和卧推的 1 重复最大值(RM),等长膝关节伸展力量和反向跳跃(CMJ)高度。结果表明,SUP 组通常在肱三头肌、股直肌的所有部位和股外侧肌的近端区域的肌肉厚度增加较大。MF-BIA 表明,瘦体重的增加有利于 SUP。SUP 组的深蹲 1RM 更大;卧推 1RM 和等长膝关节伸展在两种情况下相似。CMJ 的适度增加有利于 UNSUP。总之,我们的发现表明,监督式 RT 可促进年轻的抗阻训练个体更大的肌肉适应,并增强运动依从性。