Fisher James P
Department of Sport and Health, Solent University, East Park Terrace, Southampton, UK.
Sports Med. 2025 May;55(5):1135-1143. doi: 10.1007/s40279-025-02192-8. Epub 2025 Mar 5.
There is a growing body of research supporting the acute and chronic benefits of supervision during strength training. However, to date, there has been a lack of clarity within the terminology used, as well as when considering the differences between supervision and facilitation, and connections between supervision, feedback and attentional focus. Multiple articles have identified a lack of transparency in previous research and a need for greater detail on key elements which form the basis of supervision. The aim of this review is to discuss supervision as a construct within the parameters of strength training, including differentiating characteristics along a spectrum from supervision to facilitation, the use of different mediums (one-to-one, small group and virtual) and the effects of internal feedback (including perceptions and measures of effort), external feedback (including contemporary technological approaches) and attentional focus, and augmented feedback upon performance outcome measures. Finally, this review discusses the possible importance of positive feedback within supervision and the position of personal training and strength coaching as a service industry, as well as providing context around autonomy and input on the part of the trainee. In context, this paper provides guidance for future researchers about presenting clarity and detail of supervision and feedback, while also providing practitioners with information to stimulate awareness in coaching practices.
越来越多的研究支持力量训练期间监督的急性和慢性益处。然而,迄今为止,在使用的术语方面缺乏清晰度,在考虑监督与促进之间的差异以及监督、反馈和注意力焦点之间的联系时也是如此。多篇文章指出先前研究缺乏透明度,并且需要对构成监督基础的关键要素有更详细的阐述。本综述的目的是在力量训练的参数范围内讨论监督这一概念,包括沿着从监督到促进的连续统的区分特征、不同媒介(一对一、小组和虚拟)的使用以及内部反馈(包括努力的感知和测量)、外部反馈(包括当代技术方法)和注意力焦点以及增强反馈对绩效结果测量的影响。最后,本综述讨论了监督中积极反馈的可能重要性以及个人训练和力量教练作为服务行业的地位,并提供了关于自主性和学员方面投入的背景信息。在此背景下,本文为未来研究人员提供了关于清晰呈现监督和反馈细节的指导,同时也为从业者提供了信息,以激发他们在教练实践中的意识。