International Medical School, Management and Science University, University Drive, Section 13, Shah Alam, Malaysia.
QU Health, Qatar University, Doha, Qatar.
BMC Med Educ. 2023 Oct 6;23(1):734. doi: 10.1186/s12909-023-04734-y.
Modern clinical practice increasingly relies on collaborative, cooperative and team-based approaches for effective patient care. Recently, Jigsaw cooperative learning has gained attention in medical education. There is a need for studies in Southeast Asian context to establish its effectives in developing various core competencies expected of health professionals such as interpersonal, communication, collaborative, and teamwork skills. This current study explores the impact of using Jigsaw Cooperative Learning on undergraduate medical students.
An explanatory mixed method research design was carried out on first year medical students at a private university in Malaysia. In Phase I, a survey was conducted to explore the effectiveness of jigsaw learning. Descriptive and inferential statistics were calculated using SPSS. In Phase II, a focus group interview was conducted to explore their in-depth experiences. Qualitative data were thematically analysed.
Fifty-seven students participated in the survey and seven students took part in the focus group interview. Quantitative data analysis showed a statistically significant improvement in the student's individual accountability, promotive interaction, positive interdependence, interpersonal skill, communication skill, teamwork skill, critical thinking and consensus building after jigsaw learning sessions. Qualitative data explained their experiences in-depth.
Jigsaw cooperative learning improves collaboration, communication, cooperation and critical thinking among the undergraduate medical students. Educators should use jigsaw learning methods to encourage effective collaboration and team working. Future studies should explore the effectiveness of the jigsaw cooperative learning technique in promoting interprofessional collaboration in the workplace.
现代临床实践越来越依赖于协作、合作和团队为基础的方法,以提供有效的患者护理。最近,拼图式合作学习在医学教育中受到关注。在东南亚背景下,需要进行研究,以确定其在培养卫生专业人员所需的各种核心能力(如人际交往、沟通、协作和团队合作技能)方面的有效性。本研究探讨了使用拼图式合作学习对医学生的影响。
在马来西亚一所私立大学的一年级医学生中进行了一项解释性混合方法研究设计。在第一阶段,进行了一项调查,以探讨拼图学习的有效性。使用 SPSS 计算描述性和推断性统计数据。在第二阶段,进行了焦点小组访谈,以探讨他们的深入体验。对定性数据进行了主题分析。
57 名学生参加了调查,7 名学生参加了焦点小组访谈。定量数据分析显示,拼图学习后,学生的个人责任感、促进性互动、积极的相互依存、人际交往能力、沟通技巧、团队合作技巧、批判性思维和共识建立方面有统计学意义的提高。定性数据深入解释了他们的经验。
拼图式合作学习提高了医学生的协作、沟通、合作和批判性思维能力。教育者应使用拼图学习方法来鼓励有效的协作和团队合作。未来的研究应探讨拼图式合作学习技术在促进工作场所中的跨专业合作方面的有效性。