Department of Psychiatry, Saitama Medical Center, Saitama Medical University, Saitama, Japan.
Department of Psychology, Showa Women's University, Tokyo, Japan.
Epilepsy Behav. 2023 Nov;148:109469. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2023.109469. Epub 2023 Oct 14.
Extant research elucidating the domains of knowledge and bias on epilepsy has consistently underscored a deficiency in cognizance and an inclination toward bias within non-urban areas. Investigations into geographical disparities concerning epilepsy awareness and prejudice within the Japanese context remain conspicuously absent. To address this lacuna in the literature, we undertook a post-hoc analysis to elucidate the discernible regional differentials in epilepsy awareness and the associated stigma.
From July to August 2021, we conducted an internet questionnaire survey for 310 people with epilepsy (PWE) and 213 ordinary people without epilepsy who registered on the database of the Japanese Research Company. We inquired PWE to answer the Epilepsy Self-Stigma Scale (ESSS), the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES), and the Epilepsy Knowledge Scale (EKS). We inquired to answer ordinary people without epilepsy EKS. We analyzed residential addresses separately for Greater Tokyo and non-urban areas by comparing the degree of knowledge of people with epilepsy and people without epilepsy.
The average knowledge of people with and without epilepsy in the Greater Tokyo area was 39.60 and 28.43 points, although in non-urban areas (nine regions from all over Japan except for the Greater Tokyo, Tokai region, and Kinki region), the knowledge averages were 38.44 and 28.66 points of 100. In addition, self-stigma was highest in the Greater Tokyo area: 22.99 and in non-urban areas: 22.77. An two-way ANOVA with knowledge as the dependent variable and epilepsy diagnosis status and region (Greater Tokyo area/non-urban areas) as the independent variables revealed no interaction between diagnosis and region (F(1,346) = 1.48, η = 0.003). Knowledge was significantly higher in PWE than in people without epilepsy, but we could not identify any significant difference between ESSS (t = 0.24, d = 0.03) and RSES (t = 1.16, d = 0.16) in the Greater Tokyo/non-urban areas.
We obtained specific information about regional differences in the level of knowledge and stigma about epilepsy in Japan. Because Japan underwent educational reforms after World War II and more than 90% of the population received equally advanced education, the results found no regional differences in knowledge and stigma about epilepsy. We believe collecting information about the respondents' birth and upbringing environment and conducting a thorough investigation is necessary in the future.
现有的研究阐明了癫痫领域的知识和偏见,一致强调了非城市地区认知不足和偏见倾向。关于日本癫痫意识和偏见的地理差异的研究仍然明显缺乏。为了弥补文献中的这一空白,我们进行了一项事后分析,以阐明癫痫意识方面明显的区域差异和相关的耻辱感。
2021 年 7 月至 8 月,我们对日本研究公司数据库中注册的 310 名癫痫患者(PWE)和 213 名非癫痫普通人进行了在线问卷调查。我们要求 PWE 回答癫痫自我污名量表(ESSS)、罗森伯格自尊量表(RSES)和癫痫知识量表(EKS)。我们要求非癫痫普通人回答 EKS。我们通过比较大城市和非城市地区的癫痫患者和非癫痫患者的知识程度,分别对居住地址进行分析。
在大东京地区,癫痫患者和非癫痫患者的平均知识水平分别为 39.60 分和 28.43 分,而非城市地区(除大东京、东海地区和近畿地区以外的日本九个地区)的平均知识水平分别为 38.44 分和 28.66 分。此外,在大东京地区,自我污名感最高:22.99,在非城市地区:22.77。以知识为因变量,以癫痫诊断状况和地区(大东京地区/非城市地区)为自变量的双因素方差分析显示,诊断与地区之间无交互作用(F(1,346)=1.48,η=0.003)。癫痫患者的知识明显高于非癫痫患者,但我们无法在大东京/非城市地区确定 ESSS(t=0.24,d=0.03)和 RSES(t=1.16,d=0.16)之间的显著差异。
我们获得了有关日本癫痫知识和耻辱感的区域差异的具体信息。由于日本在二战后进行了教育改革,超过 90%的人口接受了同等先进的教育,因此研究结果发现癫痫知识和耻辱感在地区之间没有差异。我们认为,未来有必要收集有关受访者的出生和成长环境的信息,并进行彻底调查。