School of Physical Therapy, Faculty of Health Sciences, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Nuffield Health Learning Foundation, Nuffield Health, Surrey, England.
PLoS One. 2023 Oct 20;18(10):e0293170. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0293170. eCollection 2023.
Patient satisfaction is a complex construct consisting of human and system attributes. Patient satisfaction can afford insight into patient experience, itself a key component of evaluating healthcare quality. Internationally, advanced physiotherapy practice (APP) extends across clinical fields and is characterised as a higher level of practice with a high degree of autonomy and complex decision making. Patient satisfaction with APP appears positive. While evidence synthesis of patient satisfaction with APP exists, no systematic review has synthesised evidence across clinical fields. Therefore, the objectives of this systematic review are 1) to evaluate patient satisfaction with APP internationally, and 2) to evaluate human and system attributes of patient satisfaction with APP.
A systematic mixed studies review using a parallel-results convergent synthesis design will be conducted. Searches of Medline, Embase, Web of Science, CINAHL, Cochrane, PEDro and grey literature databases will be conducted from inception to 18/7/2023. Studies of APP (World Physiotherapy definition) whereby practitioners a) have advanced clinical and analytical skills that influence service improvement and provide clinical leadership, b) have post-registration masters level specialisation (or equivalence), c) deliver safe, competent care to patients with complex needs and d) may use particular occupational titles; that measure patient satisfaction across all clinical fields and countries will be included. Two reviewers will screen studies, extract data, assess methodological quality of included studies (mixed methods appraisal tool), and contribute to data synthesis. Quantitative data will undergo narrative synthesis (textual descriptions) and qualitative data thematic synthesis (analytical themes). Integration of data syntheses will inform discussion.
This systematic review will provide insight into patient satisfaction with APP internationally, exploring attributes that influence satisfaction. This will aid design, implementation, or improvement of APP and facilitate the delivery of patient-centred, high-quality healthcare. Lastly, this review will inform future methodologically robust research investigating APP patient satisfaction and experience.
患者满意度是一个由人和系统属性构成的复杂结构。患者满意度可以洞察患者体验,而患者体验本身是评估医疗质量的关键组成部分。在国际上,高级物理治疗实践(APP)跨越临床领域,并以高度的自主权和复杂的决策为特征,被认为是一种更高水平的实践。患者对 APP 的满意度似乎是积极的。虽然有关于 APP 患者满意度的证据综合,但没有系统评价对跨临床领域的证据进行综合。因此,本系统评价的目的是 1)评估国际上 APP 患者的满意度,2)评估 APP 患者满意度的人与系统属性。
采用平行结果收敛综合设计的系统混合研究综述将进行。从开始到 2023 年 7 月 18 日,将对 Medline、Embase、Web of Science、CINAHL、Cochrane、PEDro 和灰色文献数据库进行系统搜索。APP 的研究(世界物理治疗定义),其中从业者 a)具有影响服务改进和提供临床领导力的高级临床和分析技能,b)具有注册后硕士水平的专业知识(或同等学历),c)为有复杂需求的患者提供安全、熟练的护理,并且 d)可能使用特定的职业头衔;将包括在所有临床领域和国家测量患者满意度的研究。两名审查员将筛选研究、提取数据、评估纳入研究的方法学质量(混合方法评估工具),并为数据综合做出贡献。定量数据将进行叙述性综合(文字描述),定性数据将进行主题综合(分析主题)。数据综合的整合将为讨论提供信息。
本系统评价将提供国际上 APP 患者满意度的见解,探讨影响满意度的属性。这将有助于 APP 的设计、实施或改进,并促进以患者为中心、高质量的医疗保健。最后,本综述将为未来方法上稳健的研究提供信息,以调查 APP 患者满意度和体验。