Psychological Sciences Department, Western Oregon University.
J Comp Psychol. 2024 May;138(2):80-87. doi: 10.1037/com0000366. Epub 2023 Oct 23.
A growing body of research demonstrates that humans can accurately perceive the emotional states of animals solely by listening to their calls, highlighting shared evolutionary ancestry. Yet, the cognitive and perceptual mechanisms underlying heterospecific emotion perception have remained open to investigation. One hypothesis is that humans rely on simple acoustic heuristics to make such judgments, for example, perceiving higher-pitched calls as reflecting heightened emotional arousal (the "pitch rule"). This could lead to accurate judgments of emotion since in most mammals, as in humans, vocal fundamental frequency (the acoustic determinant of the pitch percept) does objectively correlate with emotional arousal. In the present study, we used digital pitch manipulation to create pairs of animal calls that were perceptually identical except for pitch, and we measured human perceptions of the caller's emotional arousal using an online survey. Calls of six phylogenetically diverse species were included as stimuli. Participants attributed slightly but statistically significantly higher arousal to higher-pitched versions of the same calls. Variation in application of the pitch rule across species was not well explained by familiarity, and prior experience with cats did not significantly predict sensitivity to pitch in cat vocalizations. Cross-species variation also did not align with phylogenetic distance from humans, or the hypothetical usefulness of pitch for making accurate judgments. Thus, the pitch rule may be a "mammalomorphic" heuristic leading to accurate emotion judgments in some taxa and call types and erroneous judgments in others, depending in part on phylogenetic distance and the mechanisms of call production. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
越来越多的研究表明,人类仅通过聆听动物的叫声就能准确感知它们的情绪状态,这突显了共同的进化渊源。然而,人类感知异源情绪的认知和感知机制仍有待研究。有一种假设认为,人类依赖简单的声学启发式来做出这种判断,例如,将高音调的叫声视为情绪高度兴奋的反映(“音高规则”)。这可能导致对情绪的准确判断,因为在大多数哺乳动物中,与人类一样,声音的基频(音高感知的声学决定因素)与情绪兴奋客观上相关。在本研究中,我们使用数字音高处理来创建一对动物叫声,除了音高外,它们在感知上完全相同,我们使用在线调查来测量人类对呼叫者情绪兴奋的感知。六种系统发育上不同的物种的叫声被用作刺激。参与者认为,相同叫声的高音调版本略高但具有统计学意义的兴奋。音高规则在物种间的应用变化不能很好地用熟悉度来解释,而且对猫的先前经验并不能显著预测对猫叫声音高的敏感性。跨物种的变异也与人类的系统发育距离或音高在做出准确判断方面的假设有用性不一致。因此,音高规则可能是一种“哺乳动物形态”启发式,在某些分类群和叫声类型中导致准确的情绪判断,而在其他类型中则导致错误的判断,这部分取决于系统发育距离和叫声产生的机制。(PsycInfo 数据库记录(c)2024 APA,保留所有权利)。