Bernardi Francesca Futura, Mascolo Annamaria, Sarno Marina, Capoluongo Nicolina, Trama Ugo, Ruggiero Rosanna, Sportiello Liberata, Fusco Giovanni Maria, Bisogno Massimo, Coscioni Enrico, Iervolino Anna, Di Micco Pierpaolo, Capuano Annalisa, Perrella Alessandro
Directorate-General for Health Protection, Campania Region, 80143 Naples, Italy.
Campania Regional Centre for Pharmacovigilance and Pharmacoepidemiology, 80138 Naples, Italy.
Vaccines (Basel). 2023 Oct 10;11(10):1575. doi: 10.3390/vaccines11101575.
Real-world safety studies can provide important evidence on the thromboembolic risk associated with COVID-19 vaccines, considering that millions of people have been already vaccinated against COVID-19. In this study, we aimed to estimate the incidence of thromboembolic events after COVID-19 vaccination and to compare the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine with other COVID-19 vaccines.
We conducted a retrospective real-world safety study using data from two different data sources: the Italian Pharmacovigilance database (Rete Nazionale di Farmacovigilanza, RNF) and the Campania Region Health system (Sistema INFOrmativo saNità CampanIA, SINFONIA). From the start date of the COVID-19 vaccination campaign (27 December 2021) to 27 September 2022, information on COVID-19 vaccinations and thromboembolic events were extracted from the two databases. The reporting rate (RR) and its 95% confidence interval (95%CI) of thromboembolic events for 10,000 doses was calculated for each COVID-19 vaccine. Moreover, the odds of being vaccinated with the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine vs. the other COVID-19 vaccines in cases with thromboembolic events vs. controls without thromboembolic events were computed.
A total of 12,692,852 vaccine doses were administered in the Campania Region, of which 6,509,475 (51.28%) were in females and mostly related to the Pfizer-BioNtech vaccine (65.05%), followed by Moderna (24.31%), Oxford-AstraZeneca (9.71%), Janssen (0.91%), and Novavax (0.02%) vaccines. A total of 641 ICSRs with COVID-19 vaccines and vascular events were retrieved from the RNF for the Campania Region, of which 453 (70.67%) were in females. Most ICSRs reported the Pfizer-BioNtech vaccine (65.05%), followed by Oxford-AstraZeneca (9.71%), Moderna (24.31%), and Janssen (0.91%). A total of 2451 events were reported in the ICSRs (3.8 events for ICSRs), of which 292 were thromboembolic events. The higher RRs of thromboembolic events were found with the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine (RR: 4.62, 95%CI: 3.50-5.99) and Janssen vaccine (RR: 3.45, 95%CI: 0.94-8.82). Thromboembolic events were associated with a higher likelihood of exposure to the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine compared to Pfizer-BioNtech (OR: 6.06; 95%CI: 4.22-8.68) and Moderna vaccines (OR: 6.46; 95%CI: 4.00-10.80).
We observed a higher reporting of thromboembolic events with viral-vector-based vaccines (Oxford-AstraZeneca and Janssen) and an increased likelihood of being exposed to the Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine compared to the mRNA vaccines (Pfizer-BioNtech and Moderna) among thromboembolic cases.
鉴于已有数百万人接种了新冠疫苗,真实世界安全性研究可为新冠疫苗相关的血栓栓塞风险提供重要证据。在本研究中,我们旨在评估新冠疫苗接种后血栓栓塞事件的发生率,并将牛津-阿斯利康疫苗与其他新冠疫苗进行比较。
我们使用来自两个不同数据源的数据进行了一项回顾性真实世界安全性研究:意大利药物警戒数据库(国家药物警戒网络,RNF)和坎帕尼亚地区卫生系统(坎帕尼亚卫生信息系统,SINFONIA)。从新冠疫苗接种活动开始日期(2021年12月27日)至2022年9月27日,从这两个数据库中提取了新冠疫苗接种和血栓栓塞事件的信息。计算了每种新冠疫苗每10000剂的血栓栓塞事件报告率(RR)及其95%置信区间(95%CI)。此外,还计算了在发生血栓栓塞事件的病例与未发生血栓栓塞事件的对照中,接种牛津-阿斯利康疫苗与其他新冠疫苗的比值比。
坎帕尼亚地区共接种了12692852剂疫苗,其中6509475剂(51.28%)为女性接种,且大多与辉瑞-生物科技疫苗(65.05%)有关,其次是莫德纳疫苗(24.31%)、牛津-阿斯利康疫苗(9.71%)、杨森疫苗(0.91%)和诺瓦瓦克斯疫苗(0.02%)。从RNF中检索到坎帕尼亚地区共641份与新冠疫苗和血管事件相关的ICSR(疑似不良反应报告),其中453份(70.67%)为女性报告。大多数ICSR报告的是辉瑞-生物科技疫苗(65.05%),其次是牛津-阿斯利康疫苗(9.71%)、莫德纳疫苗(24.31%)和杨森疫苗(0.91%)。ICSR中共报告了2451起事件(每份ICSR报告3.8起事件),其中292起为血栓栓塞事件。牛津-阿斯利康疫苗(RR:4.62,95%CI:3.50 - 5.99)和杨森疫苗(RR:3.45,95%CI:0.94 - 8.82)的血栓栓塞事件RR较高。与辉瑞-生物科技疫苗(OR:6.06;95%CI:4.22 - 8.68)和莫德纳疫苗(OR:6.46;95%CI:4.00 - 10.80)相比,血栓栓塞事件与接种牛津-阿斯利康疫苗的可能性更高有关。
我们观察到,与基于信使核糖核酸的疫苗(辉瑞-生物科技疫苗和莫德纳疫苗)相比,基于病毒载体的疫苗(牛津-阿斯利康疫苗和杨森疫苗)的血栓栓塞事件报告率更高,且在血栓栓塞病例中,接种牛津-阿斯利康疫苗的可能性增加。