Maltby Amy, Underhill Ann, Woodbridge Sarah
School of Allied Health and Social Care, University of Derby, Derby, UK.
Hand Therapy Department, Kings College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK.
Hand Ther. 2023 Sep;28(3):89-102. doi: 10.1177/17589983231191867. Epub 2023 Aug 3.
In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic caused a rapid uptake of virtual consultations (VCs) to minimise disease transmission and for this reason, research into telerehabilitation has been expanding. This review aimed to map and synthesize evidence on the use of VCs in upper limb musculoskeletal rehabilitation, describe key characteristics, and identify gaps in the research.
This scoping review investigated synchronous rehabilitation consultations performed over VC. All asynchronous, wearable or pre-recorded technology was excluded. CINAHL Complete, Medline, PEDro, Google Scholar and grey literature sources were searched. Screening and data extraction were done by a single researcher. Frequency counts were used to analyse the data.
Nineteen studies were identified, with patients with shoulder injury/pain most frequently studied. Most sources (n = 9) used bespoke video programmes. Range of motion (ROM) was the most common assessment (n = 10) and exercise prescription (n = 7) was the most common treatment. Benefits included time and cost savings, maintaining therapeutic relationships and increasing patient independence. Most diagnostic assessments, except joint and nerve tension tests, were found to be reliable and valid. Studies noted increased function in activities, decreased pain and increased ROM after VCs. Limitations included restricted 'hands-on' treatment, resource and training concerns and limiting patient factors.
This review mapped available evidence and identified several gaps in the literature. Further robust research into VCs for hand/wrist disorders, ROM assessment and cost-effectiveness is needed.
2020年,新冠疫情促使虚拟会诊(VC)迅速普及,以尽量减少疾病传播,因此,远程康复研究一直在不断扩展。本综述旨在梳理和综合上肢肌肉骨骼康复中使用虚拟会诊的证据,描述其关键特征,并找出研究中的空白。
本范围综述调查了通过虚拟会诊进行的同步康复会诊。所有异步、可穿戴或预先录制的技术均被排除。检索了CINAHL Complete、Medline、PEDro、谷歌学术和灰色文献来源。由一名研究人员进行筛选和数据提取。使用频数计数法分析数据。
共纳入19项研究,其中肩部损伤/疼痛患者的研究最为频繁。大多数资料来源(n = 9)使用定制视频程序。关节活动范围(ROM)是最常见的评估项目(n = 10),运动处方(n = 7)是最常见的治疗方法。益处包括节省时间和成本、维持治疗关系以及增强患者独立性。除关节和神经张力测试外,大多数诊断评估被认为是可靠且有效的。研究指出,虚拟会诊后患者的活动功能增强、疼痛减轻、关节活动范围增加。局限性包括“动手”治疗受限、资源和培训问题以及限制患者的因素。
本综述梳理了现有证据,并找出了文献中的几个空白。需要对手腕/手部疾病、关节活动范围评估和成本效益方面的虚拟会诊进行更有力的研究。