Science Division, Bellevue College, Bellevue, WA 98007.
Biology Department, Edmonds College, Lynnwood, WA 98036.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2023 Dec;22(4):ar51. doi: 10.1187/cbe.23-05-0068.
Random call has been proposed as an inclusive and equitable practice that engages students in learning. However, this inclusion may come with a cost. In some contexts, students experience anxiety and distress when being called on. Recently, focus has shifted to critical components of random call that may mitigate this cost. We examined how community college (CC) students perceive being called on by addressing 1) benefits that help their learning and 2) characterizing the anxiety students experience through this practice. To do this, we surveyed students in six biology courses taught by six faculty members over six academic quarters. We analyzed survey responses from 383 unique students (520 total responses) using mixed methods. Qualitative responses were coded and consensus codes revealed that students saw benefits to being called on, including paying attention and coming prepared. Qualitative codes also revealed different types of anxiety, both distress and eustress. Analysis of Likert scale survey data revealed perceptions of increased student interaction with their peers in warm random call classes. Furthermore, warm random call may increase participation in class discussions, and it is not correlated with increased extreme anxiety. These data suggest warm random call used in smaller, community college classes, may contribute to students' positive perceptions of being called on.
随机点名被提议为一种包容和平等的实践,可以让学生参与学习。然而,这种包容性可能需要付出代价。在某些情况下,学生在被点名时会感到焦虑和不安。最近,人们的注意力转移到了随机点名的关键因素上,这些因素可能会减轻这种代价。我们通过以下方式来研究社区大学(CC)学生对被点名的看法:1)帮助他们学习的好处,2)通过这种做法来描述学生经历的焦虑。为此,我们在六个生物学课程中对六名教师教授的 383 名学生(共 520 名学生)进行了调查。我们使用混合方法对调查答复进行了分析。对定性答复进行了编码,共识代码显示,学生认为被点名有好处,包括集中注意力和做好准备。定性代码还揭示了不同类型的焦虑,包括苦恼和正性压力。对李克特量表调查数据的分析表明,在温暖的随机点名课堂上,学生与同伴的互动有所增加。此外,温暖的随机点名可能会增加课堂讨论的参与度,而且与极端焦虑的增加没有相关性。这些数据表明,在规模较小的社区大学班级中使用温暖的随机点名,可能会让学生对被点名产生积极的看法。