From the Combined Neurosurgical and Orthopaedic Spine Program, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC (Moskven, Banaszek, Ailon, Charest-Morin, Dea, Dvorak, Fisher, Kwon, Paquette, Street); Arthritis Research Canada, Richmond, BC (Sayre); the Department of Infection Control, Quality and Patient Safety, Vancouver General Hospital, Vancouver, BC (Gara); and the Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC (Bryce, Wong)
From the Combined Neurosurgical and Orthopaedic Spine Program, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC (Moskven, Banaszek, Ailon, Charest-Morin, Dea, Dvorak, Fisher, Kwon, Paquette, Street); Arthritis Research Canada, Richmond, BC (Sayre); the Department of Infection Control, Quality and Patient Safety, Vancouver General Hospital, Vancouver, BC (Gara); and the Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC (Bryce, Wong).
Can J Surg. 2023 Nov 15;66(6):E550-E560. doi: 10.1503/cjs.016922. Print 2023 Nov-Dec.
Current measures to prevent spinal surgical site infection (SSI) lack compliance and lead to antimicrobial resistance. We aimed to examine the effectiveness of bundled preoperative intranasal photodynamic disinfection therapy (nPDT) and chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG) body wipes in the prophylaxis of spine SSIs in adults, as well as determine our institutional savings attributable to the use of this strategy and identify adverse events reported with nPDT-CHG.
We performed a 14-year prospective observational interrupted time-series study in adult (age > 18 yr) patients undergoing emergent or elective spine surgery with 3 time-specific cohorts: before rollout of our institution's nPDT-CHG program (2006-2010), during rollout (2011-2014) and after rollout (2015-2019). We used unadjusted bivariate analysis to test for temporal changes across patient and surgical variables, and segmented regression to estimate the effect of nPDT-CHG on the annual SSI incidence rates per period. We used 2 models to estimate the cost of nPDT-CHG to prevent 1 additional SSI per year and the annual cumulative cost savings through SSI prevention.
Over the study period, 13 493 patients (mean 964 per year) underwent elective or emergent spine surgery. From 2006 to 2019, the mean age, mean Charlson Comorbidity Index (CCI) score and mean Spine Surgical Invasiveness Index (SSII) score increased from 48.4 to 58.1 years, from 1.7 to 2.6, and from 15.4 to 20.5, respectively ( < 0.001). Unadjusted analysis confirmed a significant decrease in the annual number (74.6 to 26.8) and incidence (7.98% to 2.67%) of SSIs with nPDT-CHG ( < 0.001). After adjustment for mean age, mean CCI score and mean SSII score, segmented regression showed an absolute reduction in the annual SSI incidence rate of 3.36% per year ( < 0.001). The estimated annual cost to prevent 1 additional SSI per year was about $1350-$1650, and the estimated annual cumulative cost savings were $2 484 856-$2 495 016. No adverse events were reported with nPDT-CHG.
Preoperative nPDT-CHG administration is an effective prophylactic strategy for spinal SSIs, with significant cost savings. Given its rapid action, minimal risk of antimicrobial resistance, broad-spectrum activity and high compliance rate, preoperative nPDT-CHG decolonization should be the standard of care for all patients undergoing emergent or elective spine surgery.
目前预防脊柱手术部位感染(SSI)的措施缺乏依从性,导致抗菌药物耐药。我们旨在研究捆绑式术前鼻内光动力消毒疗法(nPDT)和葡萄糖酸洗必泰(CHG)全身擦拭在预防成人脊柱 SSI 方面的有效性,并确定我们机构因使用该策略而节省的费用,以及确定与 nPDT-CHG 相关的不良事件。
我们对 13493 例(平均每年 964 例)接受急诊或择期脊柱手术的成年(>18 岁)患者进行了 14 年前瞻性观察性时间序列研究,分为 3 个特定时间组:本机构 nPDT-CHG 方案实施前(2006-2010 年)、实施期间(2011-2014 年)和实施后(2015-2019 年)。我们使用未调整的双变量分析来检验患者和手术变量随时间的变化,并使用分段回归来估计 nPDT-CHG 对各时期每年 SSI 发生率的影响。我们使用 2 种模型来估计每年预防 1 例 SSI 的 nPDT-CHG 成本和通过 SSI 预防的年度累计节省成本。
在研究期间,13493 例患者(平均每年 964 例)接受了择期或急诊脊柱手术。2006 年至 2019 年,平均年龄、平均 Charlson 合并症指数(CCI)评分和平均脊柱手术侵袭性指数(SSII)评分分别从 48.4 岁增加到 58.1 岁、从 1.7 分增加到 2.6 分和从 15.4 分增加到 20.5 分(<0.001)。未调整分析证实,nPDT-CHG 显著降低了 SSI 的年度数量(74.6 至 26.8)和发生率(7.98%至 2.67%)(<0.001)。在调整平均年龄、平均 CCI 评分和平均 SSII 评分后,分段回归显示每年 SSI 发生率绝对降低了 3.36%(<0.001)。每年预防 1 例 SSI 的估计成本约为 1350-1650 美元,估计每年累计节省成本为 248.4856-249.5016 美元。nPDT-CHG 未报告不良事件。
术前 nPDT-CHG 给药是预防脊柱 SSI 的有效策略,具有显著的成本节约。鉴于其快速作用、抗菌药物耐药风险低、广谱活性和高依从性,术前 nPDT-CHG 去定植应成为所有接受急诊或择期脊柱手术患者的标准治疗方法。