Pain Management Centers of America, Paducah, KY and Evansville, IN; LSU Health Science Center, New Orleans, LA.
University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY.
Pain Physician. 2023 Nov;26(7):557-567.
Various regulations and practice patterns develop on the basis of Local Coverage Determination (LCD), which are variably perceived as guidelines and/or mandated polices/ regulations. LCDs developed in 2021 and effective since December 2021 mandated a minimum of 2 views for final needle placement with contrast injection which includes both anteroposterior (AP) and lateral or oblique view. Radiation safety has been a major concern for pain physicians and multiple tools have been developed to reduce radiation dose, along with improvement in technologies to limit radiation exposure while performing fluoroscopically guided interventional procedures, with implementation of principles of As Low As Reasonably Achievable (ALARA). The mandated 2 views of epidural injections have caused concern among some physicians, because of the potential of increased exposure to ionizing radiation, despite application of various principles to minimize radiation exposure. Others, including policymakers are of the opinion that it reduces potential abuse and improves safety.
To assess variations in the performance of epidural procedures prior to the implementation of the new LCD compared with after the implementation of the new LCD by comparing time and dosage for all types of epidural procedures.
A retrospective, case controlled, comparative evaluation of radiation exposure during epidural procedures in interventional pain management.
An interventional pain management practice and a specialty referral center in a private practice setting in the United States.
The study was performed using the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) criteria. The main outcome measure was radiation exposure time measured in seconds and dose measured in mGy-kG2 (milligray to kilogray squared per procedure).
Changes in exposure and dose varied by procedural type and location. Exposure time in seconds increased overall by 21%, whereas radiation dose mGy-kG increased 133%. Fluoroscopy time increased most for lumbar interlaminar epidural injections of 43%, followed by 29% for cervical interlaminar epidural injections, 20% for caudal epidural injections, and 14% for lumbar transforaminal epidural injections. In contrast, highest increases were observed in the radiation dose mGy of 191% for caudal epidural injections, followed by 173% for lumbar interlaminar epidural injections, 113% for lumbar transforaminal epidural injections, and the lowest being cervical interlaminar epidural injections of 94%. This study also shows lesser increases for cervical interlaminar epidural injections because an oblique view is utilized rather than a lateral view resulting in a radiation dosage increase of 94% compared to overall increase of 133%, whereas the duration of time of 29% was higher than the overall combined duration of all procedures which only increased by 21%.
A retrospective evaluation utilizing the experience of a single physician.
The results of this study showed significant increases in radiation exposure time and dosage; however, increase of dosage was overall 21% median Interquartile Range (IQR) compared to 133% of radiation dose median IQR. In addition, the results also showed variations for procedure, overall showing highest increases for lumbar interlaminar epidural injections for time (43%) and caudal epidural injections for dosage (191%).
各种法规和实践模式都是基于局部覆盖确定(LCD)制定的,这些法规和实践模式被不同地视为指南和/或强制性政策/法规。2021 年制定并自 2021 年 12 月起生效的 LCD 规定,最终进行针放置时需要至少进行 2 次注射对比,包括前后位(AP)和侧位或斜位。辐射安全一直是疼痛医师关注的主要问题,已经开发了多种工具来降低辐射剂量,同时还改进了技术,以限制在进行荧光引导介入性手术时的辐射暴露,同时实施尽可能低的合理可达性(ALARA)原则。硬膜外注射的强制性 2 次视图引起了一些医生的关注,因为尽管应用了各种原则来尽量减少辐射暴露,但这可能会增加电离辐射的暴露。其他包括决策者在内的人则认为,这可以减少潜在的滥用并提高安全性。
通过比较新 LCD 实施前后硬膜外程序的执行情况,评估硬膜外程序执行情况的变化,比较所有类型硬膜外程序的时间和剂量。
介入性疼痛管理中硬膜外程序的回顾性、病例对照、比较性辐射暴露评估。
在美国的私人执业环境中的介入性疼痛管理实践和专业转诊中心。
研究使用了加强观察性研究报告的流行病学(STROBE)标准。主要观察指标是测量秒数的辐射暴露时间和以 mGy-kG2(每程序毫克格雷至千格雷平方)测量的剂量。
暴露和剂量的变化因程序类型和位置而异。暴露时间总体增加了 21%,而剂量 mGy-kG 增加了 133%。腰椎间硬膜外注射的透视时间增加最多,为 43%,其次是颈椎间硬膜外注射,为 29%,骶管硬膜外注射为 20%,腰椎经椎间孔硬膜外注射为 14%。相比之下,最高的剂量增加发生在骶管硬膜外注射,增加了 191%,其次是腰椎间硬膜外注射,增加了 173%,腰椎经椎间孔硬膜外注射,增加了 113%,颈椎间硬膜外注射的剂量增加了 94%。本研究还表明,颈椎间硬膜外注射的增加幅度较小,因为使用了斜位视图,而不是侧位视图,导致剂量增加了 94%,而总体增加了 133%,而 29%的时间延长高于所有程序的总体持续时间,仅增加了 21%。
利用单个医生的经验进行回顾性评估。
这项研究的结果表明,辐射暴露时间和剂量显著增加;然而,与辐射剂量中位数 IQR 增加 133%相比,总体中位数 IQR 增加 21%。此外,结果还显示了不同的程序,总体而言,腰椎间硬膜外注射的时间(43%)和骶管硬膜外注射的剂量(191%)增加幅度最大。