Suppr超能文献

促进患者和公众参与口腔健康和牙科指南实施的公民科学(GUIDE 平台)。

Citizen science to improve patient and public involvement in GUideline Implementation in oral health and DEntistry (the GUIDE platform).

机构信息

Health Services Research Unit, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK.

Dental Health Services Research Unit, Dundee Dental School, The University of Dundee, Dundee, UK.

出版信息

Health Expect. 2024 Feb;27(1):e13921. doi: 10.1111/hex.13921. Epub 2023 Nov 28.

Abstract

BACKGROUND

Citizen science is a way to democratise science by involving groups of citizens in the research process. Clinical guidelines are used to improve practice, but their implementation can be limited. Involving patients and the public can enhance guideline implementation, but there is uncertainty about the best approaches to achieve this. Citizen science is a potential way to involve patients and the public in improving clinical guideline implementation. We aimed to explore the application of citizen science methods to involve patients and the public in the dissemination and implementation of clinical guidelines in oral health and dentistry.

METHODS

We developed GUIDE (GUideline Implementation in oral health and DEntistry), a citizen science online platform, using a participatory approach with researchers, oral health professionals, guideline developers and citizens. Recruitment was conducted exclusively online. The platform focused on prespecified challenges related to oral health assessment guidelines, and asked citizens to generate ideas, as well as vote and comment on other citizens' ideas to improve those challenges. Citizens also shared their views via surveys and two online synchronous group meetings. Data were collected on participant's demographics, platform engagement and experience of taking part. The most promising idea category was identified by an advisory group based on engagement, feasibility and relevance. We presented quantitative data using descriptive statistics and analysed qualitative data using inductive and deductive thematic analysis.

RESULTS

The platform was open for 6 months and we recruited 189 citizens, from which over 90 citizens actively engaged with the platform. Most citizens were over 34 years (64%), female (58%) and had a university degree (50%). They generated 128 ideas, 146 comments and 248 votes. The challenge that led to most engagement was related to prevention and oral health self-care. To take this challenge forward, citizens generated a further 36 ideas to improve a pre-existing National Health Service oral care prevention leaflet. Citizens discussed motivations to take part in the platform (understanding, values, self-care), reasons to stay engaged (communication and feedback, outputs and impact, and relevance of topics discussed) and suggestions to improve future platforms.

CONCLUSION

Citizen science is an effective approach to generate and prioritise ideas from a group of citizens to improve oral health and dental services. Prevention and oral health self-care were of particular interest to citizens. More research is needed to ensure recruitment of a diverse group of citizens and to improve retention in citizen science projects.

PATIENT OR PUBLIC CONTRIBUTION

This project was inherently conducted with the input of public partners (citizen scientists) in all key aspects of its conduct and interpretation. In addition, two public partners were part of the research team and contributed to the design of the project, as well as key decisions related to its conduct, analysis, interpretation and dissemination and are co-authors of this manuscript.

摘要

背景

公民科学是一种通过让群体参与研究过程来使科学民主化的方式。临床指南用于改善实践,但它们的实施可能受到限制。让患者和公众参与可以增强指南的实施,但实现这一目标的最佳方法尚不确定。公民科学是一种让患者和公众参与改善临床指南实施的潜在方法。我们旨在探索公民科学方法在口腔健康和牙科领域的应用,以让患者和公众参与传播和实施临床指南。

方法

我们使用参与式方法,与研究人员、口腔健康专业人员、指南制定者和公民共同开发了 GUIDE(口腔健康和牙科临床指南实施)公民科学在线平台。仅通过在线方式进行招募。该平台专注于与口腔健康评估指南相关的既定挑战,并要求公民提出想法,以及对其他公民的想法进行投票和评论,以改进这些挑战。公民还通过调查和两次在线同步小组会议分享了他们的观点。收集了参与者的人口统计学信息、平台参与度和参与体验等数据。一个顾问小组根据参与度、可行性和相关性确定了最有前途的想法类别。我们使用描述性统计数据呈现定量数据,并使用归纳和演绎主题分析对定性数据进行分析。

结果

该平台开放了 6 个月,我们招募了 189 名公民,其中 90 多名公民积极参与了该平台。大多数公民年龄在 34 岁以上(64%),女性(58%),拥有大学学位(50%)。他们提出了 128 个想法、146 条评论和 248 票。参与度最高的挑战与预防和口腔健康自我保健有关。为了推进这一挑战,公民们提出了进一步的 36 个想法,以改进现有的国民保健制度口腔保健预防传单。公民讨论了参与平台的动机(理解、价值观、自我保健)、保持参与的原因(沟通和反馈、产出和影响以及讨论的主题相关性)以及改进未来平台的建议。

结论

公民科学是一种从一组公民中生成和优先考虑改善口腔健康和牙科服务的想法的有效方法。预防和口腔健康自我保健是公民特别关注的领域。需要进一步研究以确保招募到不同群体的公民,并提高公民科学项目的保留率。

患者或公众的贡献

本项目从始至终都有公众合作伙伴(公民科学家)的投入,他们参与了项目的所有关键方面的设计和解释。此外,两名公众合作伙伴是研究团队的成员,为项目的设计以及与项目进行、分析、解释和传播相关的关键决策做出了贡献,并且是本文的共同作者。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/a99e/10768863/fdb86c5f2e0b/HEX-27-e13921-g001.jpg

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验