LVCT Health, P.O. Box 19835, Nairobi, 00202, Kenya.
Athena Institute, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, De Boelelaan 1085, Amsterdam, 1081 HV, The Netherlands.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Dec 7;23(1):1373. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-10370-5.
Community health committees (CHCs) are mechanisms for community participation in decision-making and overseeing health services in several low-and middle-income countries (LMICs). There is little research that examines teamwork and internal team relationships between members of these committees in LMICs. We aimed to assess teamwork and factors that affected teamwork of CHCs in an urban slum setting in Nairobi, Kenya.
Using a qualitative case-study design, we explored teamwork of two CHCs based in two urban informal settlements in Nairobi. We used semi-structured interviews (n = 16) to explore the factors that influenced teamwork and triangulated responses using three group discussions (n = 14). We assessed the interpersonal and contextual factors that influenced teamwork using a framework for assessing teamwork of teams involved in delivering community health services.
Committee members perceived the relationships with each other as trusting and respectful. They had regular interaction with each other as friends, neighbors and lay health workers. CHC members looked to the Community Health Assistants (CHAs) as their supervisor and "boss", despite CHAs being CHC members themselves. The lay-community members in both CHCs expressed different goals for the committee. Some viewed the committee as informal savings group and community-based organization, while others viewed the committee as a structure for supervising Community Health Promoters (CHPs). Some members doubled up as both CHPs and CHC members. Complaints of favoritism arose from CHC members who were not CHPs whenever CHC members who were CHPs received stipends after being assigned health promotion tasks in the community. Underlying factors such as influence by elites, power imbalances and capacity strengthening had an influence on teamwork in CHCs.
In the absence of direction and support from the health system, CHCs morph into groups that prioritize the interests of the members. This redirects the teamwork that would have benefited community health services to other common interests of the team. Teamwork can be harnessed by strengthening the capacity of CHC members, CHAs, and health managers in team building and incorporating content on teamwork in the curriculum for training CHCs.
社区卫生委员会(CHC)是几个中低收入国家(LMIC)社区参与决策和监督卫生服务的机制。几乎没有研究探讨这些委员会在 LMIC 中的团队合作和成员内部团队关系。我们旨在评估内罗毕肯尼亚一个城市贫民窟环境中 CHC 的团队合作以及影响团队合作的因素。
使用定性案例研究设计,我们探索了内罗毕两个城市非正规住区的两个 CHC 的团队合作。我们使用半结构化访谈(n=16)探讨了影响团队合作的因素,并使用三个小组讨论(n=14)对回答进行三角验证。我们使用评估参与提供社区卫生服务的团队的团队合作的框架评估了影响团队合作的人际和背景因素。
委员会成员认为彼此之间的关系是信任和尊重的。他们作为朋友、邻居和基层卫生工作者定期互动。CHC 成员将社区卫生助理(CHA)视为他们的主管和“老板”,尽管 CHA 本身也是 CHC 成员。两个 CHC 的基层社区成员对委员会有不同的目标。一些人将委员会视为非正式储蓄团体和社区组织,而另一些人则将委员会视为监督社区健康促进者(CHP)的结构。一些成员既是 CHP 又是 CHC 成员。每当被指派在社区中进行健康促进任务后,担任 CHP 的 CHC 成员收到津贴时,没有担任 CHP 的 CHC 成员就会对偏袒行为提出投诉。精英的影响、权力失衡和能力建设等潜在因素对 CHC 的团队合作产生了影响。
在没有卫生系统的指导和支持的情况下,CHC 演变成优先考虑成员利益的团体。这将本应有利于社区卫生服务的团队合作转移到团队的其他共同利益上。可以通过加强 CHC 成员、CHA 和卫生管理人员的能力、团队建设以及在培训 CHC 的课程中纳入团队合作内容来利用团队合作。