Ruth Cardoso Chair, Insper, São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
School of Economics, Business, and Accounting, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2023 Dec 14;18(12):e0295572. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0295572. eCollection 2023.
The COVID-19 pandemic in Brazil has brought many challenges, particularly regarding the management of hospital capacity, and a new demand for healthcare that added to the preexisting demands, such as neoplasms, cardiovascular diseases and births. In this paper, we estimate the impact of the pandemic on the number of deaths and hospitalizations for other diseases. We construct a monthly panel data of deaths and hospitalizations for various causes by the municipality of residence and relate them to COVID-19 hospitalizations using regression models that control for municipalities fixed-effects and interactions between State and month fixed-effects. The standard errors are clustered at the municipality level. Our estimates imply that 100 more hospitalizations by COVID-19 is associated with a drop of 49 non-COVID-19 hospitalizations and an additional four deaths for other reasons (all measured per 100,000 pop.). The impact of intensive care units COVID-19 hospitalizations on mortality is larger. The groups most affected are the African Brazilians, less-educated and the elderly. Additional deaths occurred both at households and at hospitals. The main causes of additional deaths were diseases related to the circulatory and endocrine system. The decline in hospitalizations for other causes seems to be related to the overcrowding of hospitals in periods of surge in the COVID-19, alongside with the fall in the demand for care by the citizens who were afraid of COVID-19 infection. These mechanisms affected more strongly the vulnerable groups of the population. Our results highlight the importance of promoting the awareness of heightened risk of non-communicable chronic diseases during a health emergency context. This should be done preferably through already established channels with community outreach, such as the Family Health Program in Brazil.
巴西的 COVID-19 大流行带来了许多挑战,特别是在医院容量管理方面,以及对医疗保健的新需求,这增加了原本存在的需求,如肿瘤、心血管疾病和分娩。在本文中,我们估计了大流行对其他疾病死亡和住院人数的影响。我们构建了一个按月划分的死亡和各种原因住院的面板数据,这些数据按居住地的自治市划分,并使用控制自治市固定效应和州与月固定效应之间相互作用的回归模型将其与 COVID-19 住院相关联。标准误差按自治市水平聚类。我们的估计表明,COVID-19 增加 100 例住院,与非 COVID-19 住院减少 49 例和其他原因死亡增加 4 例(每 10 万人测量)相关。重症监护病房 COVID-19 住院对死亡率的影响更大。受影响最大的群体是非洲裔巴西人、受教育程度较低的人和老年人。额外的死亡发生在家庭和医院。额外死亡的主要原因是与循环和内分泌系统有关的疾病。其他原因导致的住院人数下降似乎与 COVID-19 期间医院过度拥挤有关,同时,由于公民害怕 COVID-19 感染,对护理的需求下降。这些机制对人口中的弱势群体产生了更大的影响。我们的研究结果强调了在卫生紧急情况下提高对非传染性慢性疾病风险的认识的重要性。这最好通过已经建立的社区外联渠道来实现,例如巴西的家庭健康计划。