Malik Muhammad Hammad, Jabal Mohamed Sobhi, Kobeissi Hassan, Gupta Rishabh, Bilgin Cem, Brinjikji Waleed
Department of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Department of Neurologic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA.
Interv Neuroradiol. 2023 Dec 17:15910199231219823. doi: 10.1177/15910199231219823.
Cervicofacial arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) are a significant source of morbidity. Endovascular embolization has emerged as a promising treatment technique for these lesions. However, current literature on cervicofacial AVM embolization mostly consists of single-agent oriented case series, and to date, no comprehensive study has compared the outcomes of available embolic agents.
To investigate the performance of different embolic agents in the management of cervicofacial AVMs.
We systematically searched Ovid MEDLINE, Ovid EMBASE, Ovid Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials Scopus, and Web of Science. Studies providing data for the endovascular treatment of cervicofacial AVMs were included. The data regarding complication and cure rates were collected for each embolic agent. Pooled event rates were presented as descriptive statistics.
Eleven studies comprising 204 patients were included in the review. The overall complete and partial cure rates were 62.2% (127/204) and 36.2% (74/204), respectively. Embolization failed to achieve significant improvement in only 1.6% (3/204) of the patients. The complete cure rates were 87.5% (75-100%) for n-Butyl cyanoacrylate (NBCA, glue), 80.5% (61-100%) for Onyx (Medtronic, MN, USA), and 51.5% (18-85%) for ethanol. The overall complication rate was 30% (61/204). The complication rates were 33% (12.5-53%) for ethanol, 14% (0-28%) for Onyx, and 0% for NBCA.
Our systematic review supports that endovascular embolization is an effective treatment option for cervicofacial AVMs. In our review, the use of Onyx and NBCA was associated with consistently high complete cure rates and a promising safety profile. However, more research is needed to investigate the use of different embolic agents in the treatment of cervicofacial AVMs.
头面部动静脉畸形(AVM)是发病的重要原因。血管内栓塞已成为治疗这些病变的一种有前景的技术。然而,目前关于头面部AVM栓塞的文献大多是单药导向的病例系列,迄今为止,尚无全面研究比较现有栓塞剂的疗效。
研究不同栓塞剂在头面部AVM治疗中的性能。
我们系统检索了Ovid MEDLINE、Ovid EMBASE、Ovid Cochrane对照试验中心注册库、Scopus和Web of Science。纳入提供头面部AVM血管内治疗数据的研究。收集每种栓塞剂的并发症和治愈率数据。合并事件发生率以描述性统计呈现。
该综述纳入了11项研究,共204例患者。总体完全治愈率和部分治愈率分别为62.2%(127/204)和36.2%(74/204)。栓塞仅在1.6%(3/204)的患者中未能取得显著改善。氰基丙烯酸正丁酯(NBCA,胶水)的完全治愈率为87.5%(75 - 100%),Onyx(美敦力公司,明尼苏达州,美国)为80.5%(61 - 100%),乙醇为51.5%(18 - 85%)。总体并发症发生率为30%(61/204)。乙醇的并发症发生率为33%(12.5 - 53%),Onyx为14%(0 - 28%),NBCA为0%。
我们的系统评价支持血管内栓塞是头面部AVM的有效治疗选择。在我们的综述中,使用Onyx和NBCA的完全治愈率一直很高,且安全性良好。然而,需要更多研究来探讨不同栓塞剂在头面部AVM治疗中的应用。