Nursing Department, Faculty of Medicine, Autonomous University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain.
Grup de Recerca Multidisciplinar en Salut i Societat (GREMSAS), Mataró, Spain.
Nurs Ethics. 2024 Nov;31(7):1233-1246. doi: 10.1177/09697330231217038. Epub 2023 Dec 21.
Social justice is recognized by reputable international organizations as a professional nursing value. However, there are serious doubts as to whether it is embodied in Catalan nursing education.
To explore what nursing students take away from two teaching activities led by expert patients (one presentation and three expert patient illness narratives) on the topics of social justice, patient rights, and person-centered care.
Qualitative study using a content analysis approach. The research plan included (1) think-pair-share activities (additional faculty-assisted presentation and three faculty-assisted, semi-structured scripted narratives); (2) paired reflections; (3) focus groups; and (4) content analysis of paired reflections and focus groups.
Fourth-year nursing degree students at the Autonomous University of Barcelona (UAB), Spain. Convenience sampling was used.
The UAB Research Ethics Committee did not deem it necessary to apply any specific measures. We fully explained to patients that they could decide what medical information they would share with the students that was relevant to their learning, and we provided students with guidelines about patient confidentiality, dignity, and respect.
FINDINGS/RESULTS: The students engaged in reflection about their education (recognizing that it had been centered on the professional and not the patient) and their relationship with the patient, in which they reproduced low-involvement patient care by modeling behaviors of their nurse educator. Moreover, they valued a person-centered care model with an emphasis on the emotional part but left out decision-making as an individual right of people.
The think-pair-share activities were useful to spark self-reflection among students, who identified aspects to change in their own practice, and reflected about their own education process, both of which promote change.
社会正义被一些知名国际组织认可为专业护理的价值观。然而,人们严重怀疑它是否体现在加泰罗尼亚的护理教育中。
探讨护理专业学生通过两次由专家患者主导的教学活动(一次演讲和三次专家患者疾病叙事),对社会正义、患者权利和以患者为中心的护理主题所获得的知识。
采用内容分析法的定性研究。研究计划包括:(1)思考-配对-分享活动(额外的教师辅助演讲和三个教师辅助、半结构化脚本叙事);(2)配对反思;(3)焦点小组;(4)配对反思和焦点小组的内容分析。
西班牙巴塞罗那自治大学(UAB)四年级护理学位学生。采用方便抽样法。
UAB 研究伦理委员会认为没有必要采取任何特定措施。我们向患者充分解释说,他们可以决定与学生分享哪些与学习相关的医疗信息,并且我们向学生提供了关于患者保密、尊严和尊重的指导方针。
学生对自己的教育进行了反思(认识到教育以专业为中心,而不是以患者为中心),并反思了他们与患者的关系,在这个过程中,他们通过模仿护士教育者的行为,复制了低参与度的患者护理。此外,他们重视以患者为中心的护理模式,强调情感方面,但忽略了作为个人权利的决策。
思考-配对-分享活动有助于激发学生的自我反思,使他们认识到自己实践中需要改变的方面,并反思自己的教育过程,这两个方面都促进了改变。