Department of Emergency Medicine, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, United States of America.
Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare, West Haven, Connecticut, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2023 Dec 21;18(12):e0296180. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0296180. eCollection 2023.
The correlation between hyperamylasemia and acute pancreatitis was discovered in 1929, yet another test, lipase, was shown to provide better diagnostic performance in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Subsequent studies demonstrated co-ordering amylase with lipase did not provide additional benefit, only added cost. We sought to investigate the impact of studies advocating for the obsolescence of amylase on its clinical demand. We reviewed 1.3 million reportable results for amylase over 14 years (2009-2022). The trend in utilization of amylase over this period declined by 66% along a linear trajectory (R2 = 0.97). Despite demand for amylase decreasing by an average of 17,003 tests per year, the last year of the study (2022) recorded over 100,000 results for amylase. By interpolating the decline of amylase until the utilization reached zero, we calculated amylase orders will continue for 6 more years until 2028. Tests for creatinine and lipase changed <3% over the same period. Despite a multitude of studies advocating for the obsolescence of amylase, robust demand continues. Many important clinical guidelines, a source many practicing physicians rely on, have yet to acknowledge the preference for lipase over amylase. They frequently treat the two tests as equivalent, neglecting their head-to-head comparison studies and subsequent studies advocating against co-ordering both tests simultaneously. To expedite the obsolescence of amylase, which we anticipate lasting 46 years in our case study from its initial call for obsolescence to the last orders placed, metrics created specifically to monitor the utilization of unnecessary tests are also needed.
1929 年发现了高淀粉酶血症与急性胰腺炎之间的相关性,而在 20 世纪 80 年代末和 90 年代初,另一种测试——脂肪酶被证明具有更好的诊断性能。随后的研究表明,同时检测淀粉酶和脂肪酶并没有提供额外的益处,反而增加了成本。我们旨在研究主张淀粉酶过时的研究对其临床需求的影响。我们回顾了 130 万份在 14 年(2009-2022 年)内的淀粉酶报告结果。在此期间,淀粉酶的使用率呈线性下降趋势,下降了 66%(R2 = 0.97)。尽管淀粉酶的需求平均每年减少 17003 次,但研究的最后一年(2022 年)记录的淀粉酶结果仍超过 10 万次。通过对淀粉酶的下降进行插值,直到使用率降至零,我们计算出淀粉酶的订单将再持续 6 年,直到 2028 年。同期肌酐和脂肪酶的检测变化<3%。尽管有大量研究主张淀粉酶过时,但对其仍有强烈的需求。许多重要的临床指南,也是许多执业医生依赖的来源,尚未承认脂肪酶优于淀粉酶。它们经常将这两种测试视为等效,忽略了它们的头对头比较研究和随后的研究,这些研究反对同时同时检测这两种测试。为了加速我们预计在我们的案例研究中持续 46 年的淀粉酶过时,还需要专门用于监测不必要测试利用率的指标。