Francis Deepak Vinod, Charles Aby S, Jacob Tripti Meriel, Ruban Anand, Premkumar Prasanna S, Rabi Suganthy
Professor (Anatomy), Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India.
Assistant Professor (Anatomy), Christian Medical College, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India.
Med J Armed Forces India. 2023 Dec;79(Suppl 1):S156-S164. doi: 10.1016/j.mjafi.2022.02.002. Epub 2022 Apr 4.
Histology forms an important component of first-year medical education. Unfortunately, it is limited to the practical laboratory due to the need for a microscope and good quality slides. Virtual microscopy is a recent advancement, which uses computers as an alternative to microscopes. The aim of the study was to compare virtual microscopy (VM)-based practical classes with traditional microscopy (TM)-based practical classes for two cohorts of first-year medical students, by comparing learning achieved using two different test scores as well as a qualitative assessment of student and faculty perspectives regarding the feasibility and usefulness of VM.
Each cohort of students was divided into two equal batches and each batch underwent eight histology modules of which, four utilised traditional microscopes and four utilised virtual microscopes. Quantitative analysis was performed using a theory test (which assessed preparation, theory knowledge and understanding) as well as a spotter test (which assessed identification skills, reasoning, and recall). Qualitative analysis was performed using a structured questionnaire and focus group discussions.
Modules using VM were better when compared with those using TM, showing statistically significant and better grades. Qualitative analysis performed, yielded important information as to how this technology can serve as a good adjunct to traditional histology classes in the competency-based curriculum by increasing student interest, enabling self-study, and reducing students dependence on the tutor.
VM forms a good adjunct as well as a standalone modality of learning to TM, as it improves accessibility to slides and promotes self-learning.
组织学是医学一年级教育的重要组成部分。遗憾的是,由于需要显微镜和高质量切片,它仅限于实践实验室。虚拟显微镜是一项最新进展,它使用计算机替代显微镜。本研究的目的是通过比较使用两种不同测试分数所取得的学习成果以及对学生和教师关于虚拟显微镜的可行性和实用性的观点进行定性评估,来比较基于虚拟显微镜(VM)的实践课程与基于传统显微镜(TM)的实践课程,对象为两批医学一年级学生。
每批学生分为两个相等的小组,每个小组进行八个组织学模块的学习,其中四个模块使用传统显微镜,四个模块使用虚拟显微镜。使用理论测试(评估预习、理论知识和理解)以及识别测试(评估识别技能、推理和记忆)进行定量分析。使用结构化问卷和焦点小组讨论进行定性分析。
与使用传统显微镜的模块相比,使用虚拟显微镜的模块表现更好,成绩在统计学上具有显著优势且更优。进行的定性分析得出了重要信息,即该技术如何通过提高学生兴趣、实现自主学习以及减少学生对教师的依赖,在基于能力的课程中成为传统组织学课程的良好辅助手段。
虚拟显微镜是传统显微镜学习的良好辅助手段,也是一种独立的学习方式,因为它提高了切片的可获取性并促进了自主学习。