Centre of Social Medicine and Community Health, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India.
Institute of Development Studies, Kolkata, India.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2024 Jan 2;24(1):16. doi: 10.1186/s12884-023-06189-x.
Despite the reduction in the maternal mortality ratio, barriers in obstetric care services (OCS) remain a significant risk factor for adverse maternal and perinatal outcomes in India. This review covers the 'continuum of care' (ANC, child delivery, and PNC services) and identifies multiple barriers in provisioning as well as utilization of OCS in India. We conducted a systematic review to understand the barriers using a mixed-methods approach.
PubMed, Scopus, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Science Direct databases were searched from 1 January 2000 to 30 June 2022. The methodological quality of the included studies was assessed using appropriate tools. After a full-text review of 164 studies, total of 56 studies (33 quantitative, 18 qualitative, and 5 mixed-methods studies) were finally included in the review. All the barriers were classified into five major themes: (i) individual and interpersonal barriers, (ii) social and cultural barriers, (iii) structural barriers, (iv) logistical barriers, and (v) organizational barriers. A thematic synthesis approach was used to present the findings of the included studies.
Lack of knowledge and awareness and less family support in availing the required OCS were key individual and interpersonal barriers. Negative social and cultural practices, such as belief in traditional herbs/healers, dietary restrictions, and discarding colostrum were frequently reported barriers, especially in rural settings. Poor economic status and high health service costs were the most often cited barriers to low institutional delivery and delayed ANC services. Long distances to health facilities and poor road conditions were the most frequently reported logistical barriers. On the provisioning side, poor quality of treatment, shortage of drugs and equipment, and non-cooperative attitude of health professionals were the most significant barriers.
This review identified several important barriers ranging from individual and cultural to structural, logistical, and organizational, which are prevalent in India. To mitigate the barriers, the governments need to develop strategies at the individual and organizational levels. Innovative interventions and program implementation at the community and village levels could also be contributory steps towards improving OCS utilization in India.
尽管孕产妇死亡率有所下降,但在印度,产科保健服务(OCS)方面的障碍仍然是不良孕产妇和围产儿结局的一个重要危险因素。本综述涵盖了“护理连续体”(ANC、分娩和 PNC 服务),并确定了印度提供和利用 OCS 方面的多个障碍。我们使用混合方法学进行了系统综述,以了解这些障碍。
从 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2022 年 6 月 30 日,我们在 PubMed、Scopus、Web of Science、Google Scholar 和 Science Direct 数据库中进行了搜索。使用适当的工具评估纳入研究的方法学质量。在对 164 项研究进行全文审查后,最终有 56 项研究(33 项定量研究、18 项定性研究和 5 项混合方法研究)纳入了综述。所有的障碍被分为五个主要主题:(一)个人和人际障碍;(二)社会和文化障碍;(三)结构障碍;(四)后勤障碍;(五)组织障碍。采用主题综合方法呈现纳入研究的结果。
缺乏知识和意识以及在获得所需 OCS 方面获得的家庭支持不足是主要的个人和人际障碍。在农村地区,经常报告的负面社会和文化习俗,如对传统草药/治疗师的信仰、饮食限制和丢弃初乳,是重要的障碍。经济状况差和高昂的医疗服务费用是低机构分娩和延迟 ANC 服务的最常见障碍。距离卫生设施远和道路状况差是最常报告的后勤障碍。在供应方面,治疗质量差、药物和设备短缺以及卫生专业人员的不合作态度是最重要的障碍。
本综述确定了印度存在的一系列重要障碍,包括个人和文化障碍、结构障碍、后勤障碍和组织障碍。为了减轻这些障碍,政府需要在个人和组织层面制定战略。在社区和村庄层面实施创新干预措施和方案也可能是改善印度 OCS 利用的有益步骤。