Department of Biomedical Engineering, College of Chemistry and Life Sciences, Beijing University of Technology, Beijing, China.
Cardiovascular Department, Peking University People's Hospital, Beijing, China.
Comput Biol Med. 2024 Feb;169:107967. doi: 10.1016/j.compbiomed.2024.107967. Epub 2024 Jan 3.
The underuse of invasive fractional flow reserve (FFR) in clinical practice has motivated research towards non-invasive prediction of FFR. Although the non-invasive derivation of FFR (FFR) using computational fluid dynamics (CFD) principles has become a common practice, its clinical application has been limited due to the considerable time required for computation of resulting changes in haemodynamic conditions. An alternative to CFD technology is incorporating a neural network into the computational process to reduce the time necessary for running an effective model. In this study we propose a cascade of data-driven and physic-based neural networks (DP-NN) for predicting FFR (DL-FFR). The first network of cascade network DP-NN includes geometric features, and the second network includes physical features. We compare the differences between data-driven neural network (D-NN) and DP-NN for predicting FFR. The training and testing datasets were obtained by solving the three-dimensional incompressible Navier-Stokes equations. Coronary flow and geometric features were used as inputs to train D-NN. In DP-NN the training process involves first training a D-NN to output resting ΔP as one input feature to the DP-NN. Secondly, the physics-based microcirculatory resistance as another input feature to the DP-NN. Using clinically measured FFR as the "gold standard", we validated the computational accuracy of DL-FFR in 77 patients. Compared to D-NN, DP-NN improved the prediction of ΔP (R = 0.87 vs. R = 0.92). Statistical analysis demonstrated that the diagnostic accuracy of DL-FFR was not inferior to FFR (85.71 % vs. 88.3 %) and the computational time was reduced by a factor of approximately 3000 (4.26 s vs. 3.5 h). DP-NN represents a near real-time, interpretable, and highly accurate deep-learning network, which contributes to the development of high-performance computational methods for haemodynamics. We anticipate that DP-NN will enable near real-time prediction of DL-FFR in personalized narrow blood vessels and provide guidance for cardiovascular disease treatments.
在临床实践中,侵入性分数流量储备(FFR)的使用不足促使人们对 FFR 的非侵入性预测进行研究。尽管使用计算流体动力学(CFD)原理从非侵入性方法推导 FFR(FFR)已成为一种常见做法,但由于计算血流动力学条件变化所需的时间相当长,其临床应用受到限制。CFD 技术的替代方法是在计算过程中纳入神经网络,以减少运行有效模型所需的时间。在这项研究中,我们提出了一种用于预测 FFR(DL-FFR)的基于数据驱动和基于物理的神经网络(DP-NN)级联。级联网络 DP-NN 的第一个网络包括几何特征,第二个网络包括物理特征。我们比较了用于预测 FFR 的基于数据的神经网络(D-NN)和 DP-NN 之间的差异。通过求解三维不可压缩纳维-斯托克斯方程获得训练和测试数据集。冠状动脉血流和几何特征被用作输入来训练 D-NN。在 DP-NN 中,训练过程包括首先训练 D-NN 以输出静息 ΔP 作为 DP-NN 的一个输入特征。其次,将基于物理的微循环阻力作为 DP-NN 的另一个输入特征。使用临床上测量的 FFR 作为“金标准”,我们在 77 名患者中验证了 DL-FFR 的计算准确性。与 D-NN 相比,DP-NN 提高了 ΔP 的预测精度(R=0.87 与 R=0.92)。统计分析表明,DL-FFR 的诊断准确性不逊于 FFR(85.71%与 88.3%),并且计算时间减少了约 3000 倍(4.26s 与 3.5h)。DP-NN 代表了一种接近实时、可解释和高度准确的深度学习网络,为血液动力学的高性能计算方法的发展做出了贡献。我们预计 DP-NN 将能够实现个性化狭窄血管中 DL-FFR 的接近实时预测,并为心血管疾病治疗提供指导。